Floppy3.5: A portable 3.5-inch floppy WiFi NAS

(github.com)

103 points | by fortran77 1 day ago

15 comments

  • netsharc 1 hour ago
    I went on a backpacking tour. My aim was to take a lot of pictures, but I didn't want to carry a laptop. So my SD card backup setup was: a Raspberry Pi clone, a card reader, a 500G Sandisk USB3 external NVMe disk the size of a credit card and the thickness of maybe 3 credit cards and a power bank.

    The backup routine was:

    1. Plug the card to the card reader, plug it into one of the USB3 ports of the Pi.

    2. Plug the NVMe disk into another USB3 port.

    3. Power the contraption from my USB powerbank.

    4. Plug the phone to the Pi on another USB port. Enable network sharing over USB.

    5. Connect Bluetooth keyboard to the phone.

    6. Open a terminal on the phone,

    7. Find out the IP address of the Pi that the phone's DHCP server gave

    8. SSH into the Pi.

    9. Run rsync to copy files from the SD card to the NVMe disk (luckily the Linux distro auto-mounts the USB storage devices).

    After all that's done I can plug the NVMe disk straight to my phone to browse the images...

    I've been thinking of creating a Pi distro that creates a WiFi network, and use a Jenkins-like web UI so I can just plug everything in and control the procedure from the phone's browser. One day..!

    • alibosworth 1 hour ago
      I've looked into this kind of thing maybe 5 years ago, and there were some (expensive) devices meant for ingesting SD cards onto SSDs (either internal or USB). Some just had buttons, and some had small screens with status etc. I think there there were some with wifi portals for management. Now it looks like there are are more cheaper options that are for a more general audience.

      Question: is there a reason that you couldn't skip the pi and just use a USB-C hub and your phone to copy from the reader to a SSD? pre USB-C I did this but it was kludgy using apple's "camera connection kit".

      • netsharc 32 minutes ago
        I wasn't sure how much power the whole copy process would take. Gemini tells me with the phone I had then even a powered USB hub would not be charging the phone when it's on USB OTG; and the killer argument is that the phone only had USB 2.0.
    • M95D 24 minutes ago
      So, why not a USB hub and use the phone to copy from card reader to NVME? Or even simpler, just the NVME and put the card directly into the phone?

      No powerbank, no Raspberry clone, no card reader, no networking, no ssh.

    • walrus01 1 hour ago
      Out of curiosity wouldn't it have been possible to do the same with a small four port USB-C hub plugged into an android phone? And then plug two things into the USB-C hub, a microsd-to-usb reader and the USB3 external NVME drive. This would allow for the full set of CLI file system manipulation tools and things like rsync to be run on the mounted filesystem of the SD card and/or the NVME drive, assuming installation of something like termux.

      On a daily basis very easy to use an android GUI file management application to copy or move all the files from the microSD card to the NVME storage, doing a bulk select and then 'move' to mounted destination. Or write a tiny shell script that can run in termux that moves all new files that don't exist in the NVME drive destination.

      If I were doing this and I had some reasonable level of confidence in the wifi where I was staying temporarily, I'd try to set up a script to periodically do an incremental back up from the mounted filesystem of the NVME drive to a small fileserver that lives in my home office, via VPN.

  • accrual 3 hours ago
    Very cool project! I particularly like the display on top and the fact you can get a visual readout of the floppy disk state without dumping and analyzing the image on a PC.

    I have a Sony Mavica camera that sees some use, they're fun for taking on walks and collecting some 2000s style photos. I usually dump it on a old PC for the full effect, but a wireless floppy drive like this would certainly be an upgrade for the modern Mavica or floppy disk user. They exist! There's also a subreddit dedicated to Mavicas and their photos if anyone is interested to see how they look:

    https://old.reddit.com/r/Mavica/

  • tombert 2 hours ago
    Tangential, but I did something very similar out of morbid curiosity a couple years ago with an LTO-6 deck. I set it up with my server, and served it with NFS.

    It actually wasn't quite as bad as it sounds for reading, but writing never really worked very well. I don't know the details of how NFS works well enough to say, I'm wondering if it does some kind of out-of-order writing that doesn't work with the WORM-style LTO standard.

  • Aurornis 2 hours ago
    So many amazing details in this project:

    > The LCD looks like a segment display. Unused segments and icons show as light "ghosts" and come on in dark ink when they are active.

    Attention to detail is second to none. I bet this feels satisfying to hold and operate, too.

  • kube-system 3 hours ago
    I love the filament color. I know there's a few of these retro beige filaments around, anyone know which one this is?
  • luckystarr 5 hours ago
    I need this to store my encryption and signing keys. This would be awesome. The definitely fit and I can put the floppys in rhe safe. :)
    • edoceo 3 hours ago
      I print mine on paper (with QR) and put that in the safe.
    • verelo 4 hours ago
      Long as you have another backup, and don't have any magnets around...yeah that's not a bad idea.
      • varispeed 3 hours ago
        I have 40 years old floppies working just fine.
        • verelo 3 hours ago
          Me too, in fact I'm sure I've got some that might be closer to 50 from the late 70's. The issue I see is this: I've also had plenty of experiences where i wrote to a floppy and 15 minutes later I'm having issues getting the data back.

          Your milage may vary?

    • Muromec 4 hours ago
      That's one way to never decrypt anything.
      • Aldipower 3 hours ago
        But only for the thief, because he doesn't have a floppy drive! It's really perfect.
        • a012 3 hours ago
          Thief today would throw the disc out because he would’ve thought who put a save button into a safe?
  • keito 1 hour ago
    So cool! I love the period-inspired UI. Fits right in with Sony hardware from that era :)
  • makmanalp 3 hours ago
    For some reason I thought it'd be the reverse ... a NAS that presents itself as a floppy to access large amounts of data on, say, an amiga :-)
    • scoot 1 hour ago
      I have a USB hard drive enclosure that can present ISO images as CDs, so that seems perfectly doable. The challenge would be the hardware interface a computer such as an Amiga is expecting, although a system driver could take care of that so long as the device can be connected at all
      • xp84 1 hour ago
        really with the BlueSCSI already existing we have something even better for most systems. Various "FloppyEmu" boards are, I think, the alternative for systems without SCSI, though those definitely have to be designed to emulate the various proprietary disk drives each system used.

        Though I don't deny that it would be cool to have a "magnetic" interface, which would in theory work on any device that shared the physical format.

        Closest we've come is this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0QFvj2HpCu0

        But while it works with normal drives, it requires a special driver rather than truly pretending to be a disk.

        • makmanalp 24 minutes ago
          Didn't know about any of this, thanks both! Does make sense that holding on to the magnetic interface is probably not the best way to go
  • robflynn 2 hours ago
    I love this! Such a cool little project and great attention to detail.
  • mlhpdx 3 hours ago
    So many acronym collisions. I came here for the Network Access Server. That said, nice project.
    • neogodless 2 hours ago
      Did you ever figure out why they include NAS in the name? It does not seem to be network attached storage... does it mean something else here?
  • cm-t 4 hours ago
    oh, that's the save icon that now save things to sdcard
  • reboot81 4 hours ago
    This is the future!
  • sandworm101 4 hours ago
    Question: Can I get one for a modern 2.5" SSD and/or NVMEs?

    I am often on group trips where we end up sitting somewhere for hours on end without cell signal (military, hurry up and wait). A pocket-sized NAS that could plug into power and share a media library via wifi to nearby devices would be VERY useful. I have toyed with this using a phone/tablet to share but it was always tricky. A dedicated portable NAS would be much easier.

    • netsharc 1 hour ago
      PirateBox was a project: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PirateBox , but their website is gone now. I even have a TP-Link "3G modem with access point" that I got it to run on.

      https://well-it-wasnt-me.github.io/PirateBox/

      https://www.instructables.com/Raspberry-Pi-PirateBox/

    • dspillett 2 hours ago
      > A pocket-sized NAS that could plug into power and share a media library via wifi to nearby devices would be VERY useful.

      This already exists. There are many portable WiFi APs out there. Some of them have a built-in battery or can be powered via USB so you can use some other portable power source (which could of course be one of your devices you want to connect via its AP), so you don't even need to have wired power to plug them into for short use.

      The media sharing side isn't massively advertised as the main feature most want is to use them to share a cell connection (or another WiFi connection), and perhaps offer VPN access over that connection, but a number of them have USB ports that are cable of powering and mounting (depending on filesystem of course) an SSD so its contents can be shared via an HTTP interface or maybe a common file share protocol like SMB.

      Even if direct media sharing is not supported, you can arrange that from one of the devices that you connect to the AP.

      A quick search for “portable hotspot” and “travel router” finds no-name devices claiming 8-to-10 hours use time per battery charge (obviously take that with a pinch of salt!), just mobile->WiFi/WiFi->WiFi bridge or plain AP (no VPN or file sharing), for £17, and devices from more recognised companies for ~£30. Units with built-in VPN support (or running OpenWrt where you can probably add that yourself) start at more like £40 (GL.iNet devices claim OpenVPN and WireGuard support, I assume that is similar on other devices but you'd have to find more detailed specs than the sales page to check that). There are fewer offering built-in storage sharing than I expected but they are available (though with storage via SD or USB - I'm sure I've seen units with the option of an internal NVMe or SATA drive advertised but none came up in the first pages of my search results).

      • sandworm101 39 minutes ago
        I have tried some router options over the years without luck. They are not ready for a multi-user sharing scenario (10+ devices). It isn't the wifi but the USB interface that usually gives up, which is why I think an NVME option would be better. The one that actually worked was my home router. It was total overkill and much too big but could stream properly from usb to multiple devices.

        It sounds petty, but even having to plug in a USB drive to an external port is not ideal as they break easily. I would prefer a barrel jack over an easily-broken USB-C (I have a couple barrel-USB-c adapters). Internal lithium batteries are a no-go due to flying/packing/mailing rules.

        Ideal package: Something the size of a coke can, with only a power port, that can share a 1 or 2TB media library amongst 10-20 devices within a 50-foot range. No fiddly bits to break, no external drives. Something that could be dropped a couple times without issue. Encrypted file containers (veracrypt) and rocket.chat would be stretch goals.

        Doing research in the last couple hours, some of the new rugged Pi cases with M.2 ports seem be the way to go.

    • afavour 4 hours ago
      I bought a travel router I’m really happy with. Haven’t used its USB port for storage but it says that’s supported:

      https://www.gl-inet.com/en-us/pages/travel-routers

      • sandworm101 3 hours ago
        I tried with a different travel router a few years back but the USB interface was a bottleneck. And I would like to keep everything in a single box. If I was going to revisit the project, there are some NVME options for the Pi but then I have to print a special case and the project gets big/expensive fast.
    • whaleofatw2022 2 hours ago
      The StationPC Pocketcloud is really nice, although pricy. It's got an SD card reader so you can incrementally back up photos from a camera (well, so long as your camera uses SD cards,) a built in battery so you van use it unplugged for a little while, and there is an optional dock that can hold a second NVME to back up what is on the device itself.

      Again, pricy, but it is really nice as a photographer.

    • Muromec 4 hours ago
      >Question: Can I get one for a modern 2.5" SSD and/or NVMEs? >A pocket-sized NAS that could plug into power and share a media library via wifi to nearby devices would be VERY useful

      This sounds like a job for any something-pi shaped device with PCIE port and AP capability. opi rv2 is pretty small, but I don't remember if it can do wifi ap

    • libria 2 hours ago
      No experience with it, but sounds like StationPC pocketcloud is near to what you're looking for.
    • away0g 3 hours ago
      This is a real and kinda old product. Ive used it many times in this exact scenario. RAVPower FileHub
      • ramses0 2 hours ago
        Mine was `Monster Digital OTG Cloud NAS Wireless 802.11N Storage` ... 2000mAh battery, wifi, micro sd-card, and a HILARIOUSLY insecure linux system powering the whole thing. Certainly there's modern versions out there!
        • away0g 37 minutes ago
          SAME lol, apparently not. I looked around, noone is making modern versions of these types of gadgets.
    • dexterdog 4 hours ago
      Wouldn't that be easier to just do with one of your devices?
  • sleepybrett 2 hours ago
    this can only be an elaborate prank.
  • peterleiser 4 hours ago
    Cool project. But fyi to others that if you just want to read floppies generally, you can buy a 3.5" floppy disk drive that plugs into USB for $15 on Amazon and have it delivered today.