39 comments

  • bigwheels 19 hours ago
    If you actually try out a lot of these solutions there are almost always 2 major issues:

    1. Challenging to get running properly.

    2. User experience often leaves much to be desired.

    It quickly became clear I was better off spending time and energy on problems directly tied to revenue, not managing operational infrastructure from the ground up.

    • ben_d 17 hours ago
      If you're interested in an opinionated, non-self-hosted Slack alternative could check out Bema[1]. It enforces threading and async communication with an option to break glass for truly urgent matters. Has bidirectional sync with your existing Slack workspace's public channels. Voice/video calling are being added this week. (Disclosure: I'm the founder)

      [1] https://getbema.app

    • itake 18 hours ago
      Coolify actually makes the update and processing pretty good.

      With AI, you can fix any UX issues that bother you with relative low cost.

    • mrtesthah 18 hours ago
      Are agent-driven DevOps for self-hosting a thing yet?
      • __m 9 hours ago
        I'm guilty of doing that, nothing critical, but still
      • mrbungie 18 hours ago
        I mean, nothing stops you from writing IaC (infrastructure as code) with AI assistance.
        • herpdyderp 17 hours ago
          This is how I self host and it’s great!
          • warkdarrior 17 hours ago
            I don't know, I tried to get Claude to do upgrades to my self-hosted stuff (all using Docker images from online repos) and completely messed up any attempts to automate shadow deployments.
            • mrbungie 17 hours ago
              In my experience, infrastructure work with agents isn't as hands-off as with "typical" code, but with guidance is good enough. Mostly terraform and k8s/helm code though.
    • khizar0 8 hours ago
      [flagged]
    • steve_taylor 8 hours ago
      That's because this is no-effort Claude slop.
      • ben_d 4 hours ago
        This website may be, but the platforms it links out to were mostly started in the pre-LLM era. Zulip and Mattermost have existed for at least a decade at this point.
  • EvanAnderson 22 hours ago
    The biggest blocker for using free/libre/open-source email for my Customers has been calendaring. People who have used Outlook / Exchange for calendaring really get hooked and getting them to use something else is difficult. The "Free/Busy" functionality for others' calendars, rooms, and resources shown during invitations is very handy. I can understand why people wouldn't want to lose that.
    • sylvinus 22 hours ago
      Agreed! We've been building a new calendar app [1] for French public workers and all the workflows around invites, free/busy, conflicts, resources and online meeting links are critical to get right to get any chance of converting Outlook users.

      [1] https://github.com/suitenumerique/calendars

    • imglorp 5 hours ago
      This has been the case for some 30 years now!

      It's time for an interoperable overthrow of the incumbent. Open source can now do so much better than the rotting old corpse we've been chained to.

    • darksim905 21 hours ago
      An observation/complaint I have related to this with Google's calendar/scheduling:

      I've noticed that the transparent/ease of use of scheduling Microsoft Teams/Outlook Meetings in general doesn't translate well to people doing it by hand in Google's ecosystem. If you're creating a Google Meet, that's fine but I notice that people tend to create Zoom meetings and put the meeting URL in the wrong spot, or, the join information isn't something you can easily copy to your clipboard if you want to join manually, or have multiple versions of a meeting software installed.

    • flaburgan 19 hours ago
      Isn't Nextcloud doing this for a while?
  • dagss 19 hours ago
    The one big important thing is identity / SSO for companies. Don't see it on the list.

    Even if you somehow manage to train your employees to use strong passwords and password managers, if someone stops working at a company it is a lot to manage deleting user accounts in all the systems one is using.

    Microsoft Entra is basically the reasons people still use other Microsoft products. (Same story for Google just much smaller market share.)

    • pratio 40 minutes ago
      I've had huge success with https://goauthentik.io/ and will highly recommend.
    • number6 11 hours ago
      You might want to look at Zitadel
    • zokier 19 hours ago
      freeipa + keycloak
      • warkdarrior 17 hours ago
        The integration is what kills you. Every SaaS system is just slightly different.
    • sublinear 11 hours ago
      1000% this. It's not just a matter of opinions or the UX.
    • cryptonector 19 hours ago
      Write your own.
      • bigfatkitten 19 hours ago
        DIY authentication almost always ends terribly, and there are plenty of reasonably well proven options in this space.
        • cryptonector 14 hours ago
          Wrong. We did it at $WORK and it went great. We used standards, of course.
          • ra 7 hours ago
            care to share the URL?
  • bryanhogan 8 hours ago
    I thought this was just vibe-coded and am surprised to see it stay so long on the HN front page, e.g., "A sensible default, not the only answer."

    I tried looking for a Notion alternative. The first recommendation is Outline, which is not open-source, lacks the main feature that makes Notion different from typical note-taking applications, its Databases, and it's missing other things.

    A more relevant option is AppFlowy, which is mentioned second, but it calls it a look-alike, which is also incorrect. Who made this list?

    • VulgarExigency 6 hours ago
      Claude made it.
    • kappyuware 4 hours ago
      Very obvious that it was vibe-coded, if your search returns no results it will simply show this message: "Nothing in the catalog matches (name) yet. The catalog is a folder of JSON files, and additions are welcome.", which I find hilarious
      • zerocool0101 1 hour ago
        good catch, it's fixed now search no longer returns mailcow for “docker”. The JSON-files message is replaced by a link to request the tool.
  • raybb 1 day ago
    How are people liking Zulip these days? Every time I've played with it there are still quite a few rough edges but since they rewrote the native apps I suspect it's gotten better?

    Unfortunately, I'm not in any community that actively uses Zulip so haven't had much real experience.

    • JoshTriplett 23 hours ago
      I use Zulip every day, and it works incredibly well. There are still rough edges, but it's improving regularly.

      The model of having threads within channels provides great organizational help. But also, these days, if you want to have a "general chat" in a channel that isn't in a thread, you can optionally do that. (I'd recommend not jumping to that just because you're coming from Slack/Discord and not accustomed to threads; give yourself some time to try them. But it can be useful for a subset of channels; some people like it or casual/social channels, for instance. I personally like threads for those too, though.)

      Also, the integration and API are easy, and bots and similar are easy to write. You can also arrange to have emails turn into posts on a channel.

      Despite what the site says, you don't have to self-host. The software is Open Source, and you absolutely can if you want to. But you can also use the hosted version, either free or paid, and save yourself the trouble, knowing that you can always move to self-hosted later.

      I use the app on mobile, but just use the web version on desktop, in a pinned tab.

      (Disclaimer: I'm on the board of the Zulip Foundation.)

      • bityard 5 hours ago
        Your whole comment is worded to sound like you're some innocent bystander who just happens to know about Zulip... It would come of as far more honest if you put that disclaimer about your relationship to the product at the very top.
    • l9o 23 hours ago
      I use it every now and then when contributing to open source projects that use it. I mostly just use the web client from a browser. It seems like the macOS client is still just a wrapper around it so I don't see the point of using it. I haven't tried any mobile apps.

      Overall it's a nice experience and I like how communication is more asynchronous like forums and not as noisy as something like Slack. The UI could be a bit more polished, but it's good enough.

    • lexx 16 hours ago
      Zulip is incredible. My company uses it for comms. I love the design. It's not the same boring design every other app has. Also the topcs are brilliant.
  • richardcrng 23 hours ago
    Very helpful to see a bunch of these together.

    OP: I'd be curious about your personal stack? A bit of your story / motivation here would be interesting, too!

    I'm seeing some things pop up where open-source tools are more paradigm-breaking, e.g.

    - Ink and Switch's Patchwork[1] is a very malleable[2] piece of software

    - Imbue's Studio[3] looks pretty accessible and fun from a user perspective

    My theory of change: make open-source more powerful than the closed alternatives, e.g. a single connected database that powers tasks, messages and projects.

    -> Connected context wins in the age of agents! Repo here: https://github.com/withnative/native

    [1] Very cool demo at Local-First Conf 26: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4UxGijnuXEs

    [2] As you'd expect given their Malleable Software essay https://www.inkandswitch.com/essay/malleable-software/

    [3] https://imbue.com/product/studio -- I think technically not OSI-approved (BSL or FSL, off the top of my head), but imo still a great thing to check out. Studio is also a bit more 'use your data from within SaaS apps' rather than get out of them, however Imbue also has `datalib` as an export tool: https://github.com/imbue-ai/datalib

    • masfuerte 1 hour ago
      It's like OLE and emacs eloped to the web, had a baby and named it Patchwork. It's very cool.
    • iFreilicht 19 hours ago
      Patchwork is so awesome! It feels to me like it solves so many problems people aren't even aware of, it's one of the most innovative and important projects in terms of UX I've seen in years. But it's research-grade and the entire security story is basically non-existent right now; there's no permission management at all. So it's still early days, let's see if it will ever be production-ready.
      • richardcrng 18 hours ago
        > It feels to me like it solves so many problems people aren't even aware of, it's one of the most innovative and important projects in terms of UX I've seen in years.

        I share this sentiment hugely. I found watching the demo so delightful -- a similar feeling to watching a great magician's performance. (It was both the actual demoed tech and also the excellent job their team did in the choreography of it all.)

        > it's research-grade and the entire security story is basically non-existent right now; there's no permission management at all. So it's still early days, let's see if it will ever be production-ready.

        Yes, I do see this as a challenge as well -- and, to be honest, I think there are adoption challenges for things which have that level of paradigm-shift. Patchwork is probably most fun and thrilling for people who have this creative and playful spirit / muscle for their tools, and I think most people can get to that point of having that spirit... but I also think that the vast majority of people are not yet there. What to you and me might seem incredibly exciting and full of possibilities is perhaps bewildering and confusing to mainstream users.

        (But maybe it's enough for a tool to have a passionate niche, and/or maybe that pushes into the mainstream eventually!)

        • iFreilicht 1 hour ago
          I think I get what you're saying, but it feels the only part that's missing for regular users to understand the appeal is to have some sort of discovery mechanism for tools (and of course a good catalogue of high-quality tools to choose from), similar to the App Store. Patchwork is in a way just an OS with apps, it just offers vast new affordances around how those Apps can interact with each other.

          Patchwork isn't the first tool with this idea, but it's the first that is truly open for user modification. Look at the adoption of Notion and the lesser known Microsoft Loop. I feel like many people can instantly understand the value if you just show a few good examples.

          Of course, writing your own tools or scripts is another level below that, but you don't really need that for Patchwork to be useful. HyperCard or Excel also have vast programming and automation capabilities but are still useful without ever touching those.

    • faraway9912 16 hours ago
      Thanks for checking out studio! imbue employee here. Our personal computing 2.0 essay https://ideas.imbue.com/p/personal-computing-20 underpins a lot of our Studio design choices too :)
  • HowardLien 4 hours ago
    this is epic, took me 1 min to realize this is not a new app, it's really useful to tell people how they get a replacement tool compared to current one. Just curious how did you calculate the score of each tool?
  • mikenikles 10 hours ago
    The GitHub alternatives page doesn't list https://moruforge.com.

    For obvious reasons... I only released it a few days ago :-).

    If anyone ends up reading this comment and checks out the project, please let me know your feedback.

    • burrish 7 hours ago
      make your own post advertising your project bruh
  • ianjbutler 18 hours ago
    The best exit path would have been open source funding before we were addicted to such things, and that seems like it’s still the best exit path now that we are.

    AI helps rather than hurts here too. Exactly why isn’t irc good enough to be your slack? If it really wasn’t before then the distance between actual and desired state is more narrow than ever before. Consequences for Hail corporate are clear, the off ramp is clear, let’s get to it.

  • savolai 20 hours ago
    Anyone here have experience with Siyuan as Notion alternative? All the alternatives on exitpath are subpar even by their own comparisons.
    • alok-g 7 hours ago
      I just looked into it (not tried). The desktop app looks good, and there are mobile apps too.

      My own personal requirement is to use Syncthing to sync notes across my devices. Siyuan does not seem to support that.

  • gitowiec 21 hours ago
    Don't go to Mattermost. they changed recently their license and made it impossible to login with gitlab for small companies.
    • brammeleman 8 hours ago
      Same! Was looking to find a Mattermost alternative here.
    • Ylpertnodi 21 hours ago
      > mattermost Thanks for the heads up. Was considering, Still am, but now I have questions..
  • tengwar2 15 hours ago
    What is the issue with "MacOS terminal and closed terminals"?
    • pentakkusu 7 hours ago
      Same. I want to know why using Terminal on my Mac is bad for me.
  • MarkMarine 14 hours ago
    Feels like notion is catching a stray here. They are behind on the new documentation format (html > markdown) but I work with non-devs, and notion is a godsend.
    • canadiantim 13 hours ago
      html is new the documentation format instead of markdown? Or do you mean vice versa?
  • joshspankit 14 hours ago
    It’s time to start sharing algos, standards, and best practices instead of specific software tools.

    Like, how quickly could an agent make a self-hosted dropbox clone using docker?

  • dc_rog 15 hours ago
    Anyone switched from slack to campfire from 37 Signals? I do like the idea of either open source or buy once chat software.
  • itake 18 hours ago
    I wish Immit encrypted the photos like Google Does. If someone hacks my server, I don't want them to have access to my photos.
  • Fysi 20 hours ago
    Not too be that guy but "Microsoft Office apps, OneDrive & SharePoint files, Outlook & Exchange Online, Microsoft Teams" is more Office 365 than Microsoft 365.

    Just have a look at the venn diagram for the different M365 Enterprise/Business and Office 365 options.

    Microsoft 365 Enterprise: https://m365maps.com/files/Microsoft-365-Enterprise-Venn.htm Microsoft 365 Business: https://m365maps.com/files/Microsoft-365-Business-All.htm Office 365: https://m365maps.com/files/Office-365-Enterprise-All.htm

    • rbanffy 7 hours ago
      Not only that, but ShamePoint has a ton of integrations that lots of companies did bite into that will keep them poisoned for a long, long time.

      For smaller deployments, Plone has hierarchical access-controlled object/file storage with easily integrated workflows, very good website management (it was built for that), impeccable accessibility, but lacks file syncing and shared editing with third party office apps.

  • imperialdrive 20 hours ago
    Great timing. I had Claude work on a replacement to the Microsoft, Asana, Zendesk, Adobe (PDF) ecosystem in a much more user friendly combined UI, and it's damned good, with just the features our users (and admins!) want in just the right places. It took less than a week and $25 in tokens. Yes, it probably won't launch anytime soon, but at this rate, no reason it couldn't in a handful of months. Wild times, and even more wild times ahead!
  • Onavo 22 hours ago
    The UX of Seafile, Nextcloud, and Syncthing all leaves much to be desired compared to Dropbox/Google Drive.
    • 0x1ch 22 hours ago
      Nextcloud is unbearably clunky, and syncing notes and other content between Android and Desktop might as well not work. Landed on Syncthing for the few things I need, since this seems to handle version mismatching much better, and doesn't just wipe content if it does detect a clash.
      • esperent 16 hours ago
        > Nextcloud is unbearably clunky, and syncing notes and other content between Android and Desktop might as well not work.

        This is the complete opposite of my experience. I set it up a couple of years ago, I have the Android app and the Linux app, several colleagues have the Windows app. The file sync seems to work at least as well as Google Drive or Onedrive.

        What problems have you had?

        • 0x1ch 17 minutes ago
          I had a Nextcloud AIO instance running for a few months and I routinely ran into version conflicts with the note app and the Collabora sessions, but this was about a year and a half, two years ago? Everything else worked pretty much as you would expect it.
        • Propelloni 4 hours ago
          I support this notion. We moved our company to Nextcloud over a year ago and while there are a few problems, mainly UX-wise, syncing isn't one of them.
  • keithnz 20 hours ago
    while its an exit path of sorts, you end up with all kinds of compromises. At scale it may make a lot of sense, but not sure it's worth it at a smaller scale (other than for those want to do it based on the single desire to be on open source).
    • rbanffy 7 hours ago
      The single desire of being open source can easily become a mandate for governments, as it’s a great way to help build an indigenous IT industry.
  • qwertygnu 17 hours ago
    Tiny detail but it would make more sense to keep a consistent rating system. Look at Thunderbird for example:

    Fit: Workable 3/5 Getting data in: Trivial 1/5 Running it: Nothing to host 1/5

    All those ratings should follow a LOW=BAD and HIGH=GOOD system. Otherwise it's hard to parse whether any given option is good or not.

    Perhaps something that would've been noticed if it wasn't generated entirely by AI.

    • zerocool0101 1 hour ago
      yeah just noticed that, change it to rating dots instead, lmk what you think
  • donkeylazy456 9 hours ago
    A score of 17 for "exiting Microsoft Office" makes me laugh. You will have a ton of problems when working outside your organization. It works but won't work as you intended.
  • maxloh 23 hours ago
    OpenCloud might be a better alternative to Google Drive. It is written in Go.
  • selfsimilar 20 hours ago
    I would like to see a "Project Management" category up there with "Asana" and "Jira" as projects to escape from.
  • saturn8601 20 hours ago
    This is a lovely website. Thank you for providing it! It has inspired me yet again to think about all that I can finally offload. This is freedom and I love anything that gives us more of it. I wish I could just spend a month with no obligations and just master all these different open source tools even probably try to improve them. sigh so many things to try so little time in life. Thats how the existing providers got me hook line and sinker. That lockin when you are in a chaotic day to day is tough to overcome.
  • lightedman 19 hours ago
    Almost all of these solutions have one major blocker. It isn't accessible or easy for the typical user to figure out or utilize.

    AKA "This is made for how I do things, not how everyone else does things."

    • tengwar2 15 hours ago
      Nextcloud is on there for a few things. I run that (using Yunohost at the moment), and find it easier than trying to work out what the Microsoft equivalents are intended to do. For an end user, I would say that it's about equivalent for some things (e.g. calendar) and a bit easier for others (file sync, web access to files). But as a general point, you are perhaps right.
  • gtm1260 17 hours ago
    Another massive blocker to moving off slack now is the insane network effect of slack connect.
  • bigB 11 hours ago
    Good luck explaining to a board of directors why nothing works like it used to and when it does break (and it will break with so many 3rd party apps trying to interconnect in one environment) how there is no Microsoft to blame....only you being the one that has implemented it. Not a chance. While Microsoft has its issues.....many issues in fact, the homogeneous nature of 365/Azure/Entra makes things interconnect rather well despite the frustrations that arise
  • darkstar999 19 hours ago
    docker -> mailcow??
    • burrish 7 hours ago
      AI: "It's run with docker so it's similar no ?"
  • AndrewKemendo 17 hours ago
    Am I the only one who likes slack?

    I was an early adopter after having used mIRC nearly everyday and found it to be a comfortable place

    I’m not really sure what better async-sync range communication tool exists especially because it keeps workplaces entirely separate.

    Mattermost is “we have slack at home” and while serviceable way less capable.

    Discord is one app with many subgroups, which commingles work and play into one app way too much for my personal tastes.

    • muglug 10 hours ago
      Lots of people like Slack.

      Source: I work at Slack.

  • anuis 7 hours ago
    [dead]
  • iambruce283 6 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • hellogetkwill 10 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • nhk0371 15 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • pikann22 23 hours ago
    [dead]
  • sliechti 21 hours ago
    [dead]
  • amarinhodev 19 hours ago
    [flagged]
  • javierluraschi 22 hours ago
    [flagged]