5 comments

  • bityard 24 minutes ago
    HN headline is wrong/misleading.

    This is more of a survey to identify _potential_ suppliers of NEW CF/PC memory cards. It's not a request for bids, nor asking civilians to root around their junk drawers for cards to send off to the military.

    Reading between the lines, they are likely evaluating multiple options for modernizing whatever F-22 system this is, and need to find out if going this route is even feasible.

    • tomrod 2 minutes ago
      Good catch. This is typically "market research" by the agencies and departments performing it. Many outcomes possible, such as a BPA, an IDIQ, a sole source supplier, etc.
    • rustyhancock 20 minutes ago
      Are you sure? Don't want them to hesitate and miss blackfriday sales. You can bag 16GB CF for £20.

      They'll probably want SanDisk extreme for a super sonic jet fighter though and that's pricier.

  • vkaku 30 minutes ago
    Bought a few CF cards from Dogfish SSD (https://dogfishssd.com/) sometime ago. They are readily available on Amazon and can be bought with relatively no fuss. The company are NOT based out of the US though.

    The company that I do recommend for any industrial flash is Delkin Devices (https://www.delkindevices.com/). They are based out of San Diego, CA and I bought USB 3.0 high endurance drives from them and so far the performance of those have been solid, and it's lasted me many cycles. These are whom you'd be in contact with, for bids like these.

    It's worth expanding the supply chain options locally. If anyone needs this they'd have to get Micron or Sandisk to make and assemble them into other form factors. This part is what is harder than it looks, and would need to be done.

    • Felger 21 minutes ago
      Dogfish ? Will maybe sell to the USAF if they made them in a Dogfight fashion
      • vkaku 19 minutes ago
        It's got the shark, dog and fish marketing on it. Could work!
  • keito 26 minutes ago
    As a bit of a fun aside, Industrial CF cards are a popular stand-in for hard disks in vintage computers (since in IDE mode they can be adapted passively to IDE - they're both parallel ATA but with different pinouts). Too bad they don't make hard drive noises, though.
    • robotnikman 11 minutes ago
      >Too bad they don't make hard drive noises, though.

      Funny thing, there were CF cards which were basically mini hard drives

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microdrive

      • ben1040 9 minutes ago
        These seemed super niche, right up until they wound up in the iPod Mini en masse.
    • Symbiote 19 minutes ago
      I thought the lack of a whining motor was great. My ARM2 (Acorn Archimedes) computer is silent with a CompactFlash card.
  • nhecker 25 minutes ago
    "[...] The PC or CF card must have a storage capacity of 256 megabytes (MB) or greater [...]" I'm guessing they have some system that bootstraps off of PC cards, or stores some small amount of low-bandwidth essential things. It's interesting that it's cheaper to req. a bunch of cards & adapters than it is to retrofit & modernize. Well, I suppose that's not that surprising, if I stop to think about it; from a systems integration point it's certainly way more reliable and less risky to replace a like part for a like part, rather than redesigning the hardware to use a more modern flash storage device.
  • netsharc 26 minutes ago
    Oh my Singaporean friend Alice told me I should contact them, she has a supplier but if she does the deal through my US company it'll be a lot easier!