Show HN: Type Fighter 2

(typefighter2.com)

138 points | by torumitch 1 day ago

30 comments

  • richardcrng 1 day ago
    This is fun, nice work! Just blitzed through a few things to try it.

    I've got a background in pedagogy and I'm curious about the 'sequencing'.

    - I think it's probably the right call to introduce letters incrementally

    - I don't know whether teaching nonsense, rare combinations is the right start

    The interesting educational questions for me are:

    - which are the right letters to expose people to at the start?

    - what's the right way to expose people to those letters?

    e.g. some heuristics to consider off the top of my head:

    1. look at common words in the English language

    2. look at letters that occur frequently in those words

    3. teach those letters

    e.g. maybe `a` and `m` are plausible starters: `am`, `ma`, `mama`, `maam`, `ama` are not nonsense (vs `dj` or `fk` or whatever it was)

    To motivate that more clearly:

    - I'm a touch typer but I sometimes fumbled on e.g. 's;k;;l;;;;f;j` (to exaggerate) whereas when it starts being actual words, I fumbled far less on those.

    - What this demonstrates is "being able to touch type in a way that's useful practically" is a different skill to "being able to touch type arbitrary character strings".

    - i.e. I'm probably substantially slower at touch typing on very rare character combinations and that's almost certainly less useful for a novice to learn

    (From a learner engagement perspective, it's also probably motivation-reinforcing when they're actual words as much as possible)

    Great work though! I'm a bit of a 'sequencing' nerd when it comes to education; I think the core idea, theme + UIs etc are all very strong

    • CrillRaver 20 hours ago
      I was taught to type at school in the 1980s when we still had to use type-writers with mechanical arms for each letter. And there we also started first with the letter combinations as done in the game.

      The idea behind learning those letters is that you don't type words but a row of letters. A good typist makes no distinction in typing English, French, Portuguese or Dutch. They're just letters and they could form words, or not, shouldn't matter to a typist. Typing in DNA sequences should go as fast as your mother tongue.

      • richardcrng 19 hours ago
        Very cool that you have strong and plausible opinions on what a 'good typist' is!

        I'm wondering: do you think there's a difference between being "a typist" and being "a knowledge worker with sufficiently good touch typing for your everyday purposes"?

        I'd imagine that e.g. some professional nutritionists learn food health fundamentals in a different, deeper way to parents trying to prepare balanced meals for their children.

        A tangible example of that: "5 fruit and veg a day" (as we have in the UK) probably isn't the most rigorous way to learn about nutrition, but it's simple and practical, and I think that can be the right trade-off to make to get parents to take positive steps forwards! I like to think about the counterfactuals: it's not always about the most theoretically globally optimal approach, sometimes it's just "What helps this person take a step forward, feel good about themselves, and be encouraged?"

        • baruz 3 hours ago
          I also learned to touch type on mechanical (non-electric!) typewriters in the eighties. There is a difference, but for us, you had to learn the skill in a class. Before that, the hunt and peck system I was using on my home computer was not really sustainable for the tasks I wanted to do, writing essays and programs.

          I have watched my child run a similar program on his computer but with the incentives coming just after the home keys are learned, encouraging and rewarding sufficient speed, and yet eventually stop. It really comes down to external motivation.

        • vanderZwan 10 hours ago
          The field of nutrition (like anything medical) is vast and deep. Having actionable rules of thumb is a necessary trade-off.

          Touch typing is a skill with a very low depth to its complexity by comparison. It's matching symbols to fingers, it's teaching motor neurons how to position hands the right way (I personally suspect that the few years I tried to learn how to play the piano, which started a bit before I was taught touch typing, helped me a ton), and… I think that's pretty much it.

          I don't expect there's any advantage to be had from starting with "chunking" letters for touch typing. If anything that sounds like a premature optimization that harms more than it helps. Once the basics are covered it can probably help give speed boosts to fast typists because of faster processing speeds.

          • richardcrng 4 hours ago
            Small world: I also learned to play the piano first, and I think it helped me a bunch as well when it comes to touch typing!

            I think the piano is a very useful analogy, tbh.

            Here's things we might consider when someone learns to play the piano:

            - Help them play the simplest thing that sounds nice rather than arbitrary keys; that's motivating (analogy: recognisable words vs arbitrary strings)

            - Help them learn patterns that have reusable valuable, e.g. scales and arpeggios, vs infrequent musical combinations (analogy: common letter patterns vs arbitrary combinations)

            I agree that touch typing is not the same as being a trained nutritionist -- what I'm trying to gently suggest to the prior comment is that "Typing in DNA sequences should go as fast as your mother tongue" might perhaps be a black-and-white view of "what counts as touch-typing".

            If I learned by ear and I can play "things that sound jazzy" in a skillful way, but I can't play discordant modern music by ear, maybe that doesn't matter! Maybe I don't need to be able to cover "any arbitrary piano note combination" as equally as possible -- maybe my end is "music that I enjoy playing", and maybe I've got sufficient things for those ends.

            EDIT: I think your point on neurons is good, and it also makes me reflect on something else a bit peculiar about "Typing in DNA sequences should go as fast as your mother tongue" -- for this to hold, the person probably needs to be able to type arbitrary DNA sequences with the same regularity as their mother tongue...?

            It seems both like the 'probable neuroscientific reality' as well as 'practically efficient trade-off' for us to have better wirings on "things we type more often" (and I guess it being an efficient trade-off is exaclty why our brains have evolved in that way)

    • k0morebi 14 hours ago
      n=1 but I wholeheartedly endorse this. Learned to type in elementary school. Learning a couple letters and starting to be able to type real words, even the smallest ones, felt like a big victory for me. Enough that I still remember the experience to this day, 30+ years later. Definitely motivation reinforcing. Can't imagine learning nonsense triggering the same feeling. After all, everyone can type nonsense before learning to type.
    • OrderlyTiamat 1 day ago
      > I'm a touch typer but I sometimes fumbled on e.g. 's;k;;l;;;;f;j` (to exaggerate) whereas when it starts being actual words, I fumbled far less on those.

      I had this exact experience. typing `mam` and `mama` etc would've been a better start I think. I have no pedagogical background though.

    • XenophileJKO 20 hours ago
      This is following the most common teaching method because hand placement is the most important component of traditional typing form.

      I find it really weird we would propose learning anything but the "home" row of keys in the beginning. The whole exercise of high speed typing is having a solid orientation of the hands relative to the keyboard and returning to the home row seems pretty integral to that.

      Teaching "a" and "m" without building the muscle memory of reseting to a known point seems like a recipe for disaster. You can type words better then those key combinations likely because you have already consolidated that mental process to something you don't think about.

      • richardcrng 19 hours ago
        > Teaching "a" and "m" without building the muscle memory of reseting to a known point seems like a recipe for disaster.

        Curious: (a) what % of people who touch type do you think did not learn through a specific formal programme based on a home row; (b) what % of those people do you think are 'disasters' at touch typing?

        I think you could make a reasonable case that it's suboptimal to not start with the home row, and that the (a) % would be higher for starting with the home row. As I said, I think it's an interesting educational question: "which are the right letters to expose people to at the start?"

        Would you be open to a suggestion that it's a bit black-and-white to say it's a "recipe for disaster" to do anything else?

        I think that, empirically, since people do demonstrably learn touch-typing without a disciplined building block of "two keys on the home row as my foundation for everything", your hyperbole is somewhat off the mark -- but it's great that you feel passionate about this! I think it's highly valuable for people to be opinionated about the best way for people to learn, and I hope you channel that into helping others learn

        [EDIT: to be clear, touch-typing is not an area I'm specifically passionate about the pedagogy of, and I was merely sharing some armchair musings with the OP. I'm a former maths teacher + software engineering coach, and I'm incredibly opinionated about certain sequencing decisions there, and I do genuinely think that's important]

  • WesleyJohnson 1 day ago
    Not a review of the game, but I'd like to just skip to typing words. I never learned home row. I tried in grade school, but it never stuck. I've been a software engineer now for 20+ years, been zoned out on computers for 30+ and I just never learned. I type well enough, ~120 WPM according to MonkeyType, but I was falling behind by the 3rd level on TypeFighter2 because home row just doesn't fit how I type.

    Interestingly, and thankfully, I've avoided any form of RSI and I do attribute that largely to NOT confining myself to home row - but that's just an unverified anecdote.

    • vikingerik 20 hours ago
      Same here. I've avoided any RSI from 40 years of typing, and I'm certain it's because I don't force my wrists into the home row position. I keep my wrists straight with the forearms so the hand is angled about 30º from perpendicular to the keyboard. My home positions are more like QWDC and NJIO (but not exactly, more like in the crevices between them, at whatever angle feels most natural for the wrists.)

      I agree with the other posts saying that the home-row first levels in this game feel wrong, no actual typing works like that, give me words.

    • komodo99 21 hours ago
      > Interestingly, and thankfully, I've avoided any form of RSI and I do attribute that largely to NOT confining myself to home row - but that's just an unverified anecdote.

      Big same, n+1 anecdata from me too. I've always imagined it like sequential access to keys vs. random access... I need a key, I hit a key, it doesn't really matter from whence i need to reach it from. I also seem to hold mice at a 45º angle, so there's that too... not an RSI in sight, whew.

    • ratelimitsteve 22 hours ago
      i also was shit at learning home row when i was in school in the 90s and now type over 100wpm based on a technique I call "just typing a lot all the time for a few decades". when playing this game i had a hard time thinking of it as home row and more just replaying pathways in my brain, and it caused me to try to do things like pronounce "fjf jf" as "fijif jeff" and then type it from there.
  • Kuyawa 1 day ago
    I wish I had this 40 years ago, still can't type without looking at the keyboard. A coworker 25 years ago could type looking at me while talking, I thought he was a kind of geek god and I wished I could do that. Well, after all these years I still can't
    • commakozzi 1 day ago
      We had typing class in high school as an elective back in 1992 (10th grade for me), and i didn't want to take any of the other electives. Everyone made fun of me for taking what they considered a "girl's class", but I enjoyed it so much that I took it again the next year. Glad I did, because I've been a touch typist since high school AND i got to be around all the girls. edit Also, Mario Teaches Typing was a great game that helped me practice. It seemed to follow what we were doing in typing class fairly closely.
      • KellyCriterion 1 day ago
        Same here! Back then I thought: Hell why should I learn that? Today, after 25+ years in the job, Im so glad I learnt it back then, its really great if you are capable of this.
    • vasac 1 day ago
      Even after almost three decades of using computers (counting the ZX81 and ZX Spectrum in there :) ), I still couldn’t touch type. Every few years, I’d give it another try, but the proper hand position made my wrists hurt, so I’d always have to stop. A few years later, I’d forget why I’d stopped and make another unsuccessful attempt.

      Then I built a split keyboard, and it turned out that was all I needed to learn to touch type in just two weeks. I wish I’d had one in the eighties.

    • fwlr 1 day ago
      I learned touch-typing by accident and without effort, when I bought a mechanical keyboard with blank keycaps. You can reproduce this effect for free with a permanent marker, whiteout correction fluid, a pack of small round stickers, etc. Block out half a dozen keys on Monday, by Friday your fingers will have learned where those keys are. Do another four or so each week and in a few months you are a touch-typist.
    • jbaber 1 day ago
      You can still learn from scratch if you use an alternate layout like Dvorak or Coleman. You won't fall into your existing habits or be able to look at the keys.
  • stalfie 1 day ago
    The intro with "sdfjkl" sequences and oddly specific instructions for finger positioning seems like a strange decision. It seemed like an intro trying to set up a game that only involved random strings of letters, like some strange custom control scheme. As someone who touch types at up to 100wpm, it somehow undid my muscle memory and made me second guess where the keys were, which felt bad. It wasn't until after I quit and read the comments that I realized that there were actual words coming eventually.

    I would cut the part with random letters and instructions of where to put your fingers. People who touch type already have their own unconscious technique, and any generic advice will fall flat. And non touch typers will never play or enjoy this game, or if they do any advice given there is not what will teach them. The only thing any tutorial will achieve is to make people like me bounce off immediately. Go straight to words, and then start cranking up the difficulty.

    • arijanj 22 hours ago
      That's the point, and this is the technique most commonly referred to as 'touch typing'.

      If you want, you can unlearn your custom fingerings (depending on how bad they are - for example if you only use 2-3 fingers on both hands, I'd recommend learning the 'proper' way).

      You can see the same method followed on more traditional sites like typingclub.

      • stalfie 1 hour ago
        I actually do not know how many fingers I use, and I'm on a phone right now so I can't find out... I think I use all of them? But I'm quite happy with reaching 100wpm on a good keyboard (measured on typeracer.com, which is quite strict about formatting), and more than that if you have a tolerance for small typos. I can generally express myself in writing as fast as I have ever needed to do, and I know that I'm probably already at least two standard deviations above the mean excepting professional typists. I have at least never met anyone who typed faster (and I'm in a profession that types a lot of text).

        So however suboptimal my technique is, it does not seem like a good use of time and effort to try to learn something that's allegedly better, as it already seems near the limit of what I would assume someone of my talent could reach, and because any gain would take a lot of effort and be incremental. I suspect that there are some diminishing returns, if I were a slow typer I would have more to gain, but I'm not.

      • dmonitor 20 hours ago
        QWERTY isn't the only keyboard format
    • CrillRaver 20 hours ago
      It's not a strange decision. It's to teach you how to type letters and not words. A good typist can type just as fast in French as they can in English or Dutch or Swahili. If you learn to type words, you will struggle typing in anything "gibberish" like, for example, DNA sequences.
      • stalfie 1 hour ago
        Well up until now I have never noticed myself struggling to type gibberish, although I probably rarely do. However I have no interest in ever learning a technique to type gibberish more effectively, in fact I have an active disinterest in doing so.

        So if that's the niche skill that the game is trying to teach me, that's fair, but I'd rather not learn it. And I generally find typing games fun otherwise.

    • butlike 23 hours ago
      I'm not a touch typer and I enjoyed the game. I was literally thinking to myself 'maybe I could finally learn touch-typing with this." The random strings didn't bother me. I liked that I was getting used to the 'asdf' 'jkl;' based on which finger it was on.

      I hunted and pecked this comment.

      • stalfie 1 hour ago
        Consider me pecked.
    • fcoury 1 day ago
      I experienced the very same thing. Just typed my feedback asking for straight to words/text to enable for casual play.
  • xnx 1 day ago
    Pretty cool. Also delighted to see that Typing of the Dead can be played in browser: https://retroonline.net/Windows/The%20Typing%20of%20the%20De...
  • arscan 1 day ago
    As a decent typist, I'm really just curious about skipping to the harder levels instead of grinding through dd;jjkd;. Is there a way to go right there? Or let them place into later rounds much more quickly when they destroy earlier opponents?
  • jimmcslim 22 hours ago
    With all these great games implemented in a web browser, and being keyboard-driven... I wish Vimium (Vim-style keyboard navigation extension for Chrome, see also Vimari) could somehow automatically pick up that "Hey, this page has lots of keyboard bindings, I will disable myself for this page automatically" and turn itself off for the page.
  • OrderlyTiamat 1 day ago
    I love the post game screen, it's cute! I love that I can blitz through the modals by just pressing space, keeps you in the zone of just typing.

    I did think the start with `fjjf` etc was a little wonky- for me it felt like the game really took of once actual words were introduced. Very fun!

  • KellyCriterion 1 day ago
    >game for people learning to touch type

    not sure if the best way is to throw random letters at them? In languages and writing, there are certain pattern which occure far more often than others, so wouldnt it be better for learners to write "real" content?

  • torumitch 1 day ago
    Thanks to everyone who’s given the game a go and wrote about it. I’m delighted that so many of you have played it.

    I’ll keep working on the game as time allows. It helps a lot to hear where things went wrong as well as the bits you enjoyed.

  • dvaplima 1 day ago
    Really fun! Found some trouble using a different keyboard from the American standard when reached ";", Keep up with the good work!

    Also, would be fun to see the actual leaderboards from everyone playing

  • schainks 23 hours ago
    Not too shabby! All the decades (fml) of touch typing make words super easy for me to type but those random strings of letters are now quite difficult!
  • mlok 1 day ago
    No AZERTY :(

    I guess other keyboard layouts are overlooked too. It is often the case that non-QWERTY layouts are forgotten, but in this instance, for a game dedicated to keyboards, it's a pity.

    • Tepix 1 day ago
      Look again! I saw azerty while looking for qwertz (which is also there).
  • Tepix 1 day ago
    Cool. When I figured I had to switch the keyboard layout at stage 4 or so, I lost my progress and had to start over. I stopped playing at that point.
    • torumitch 1 day ago
      Sorry about that. I made the keyboard layouts separate courses, so your old progress should still be there if you switch back. But that isn’t much help when you were correcting the keyboard.

      I’m testing a change that keeps your score across keyboards, but that alone won't fix having to repeat the lessons. Which layout were you switching from and to?

  • raghavroy 1 day ago
    An arcade/practice mode would be awesome as well!
    • bitwize 1 day ago
      (in Barry White-like voice) Practice MODE.
  • brian_herman 1 day ago
    I thought this was going to be about type theory.
  • valdrinNereth 1 day ago
    nice game, loved it. I have a problem with the keyboard though, since I'm using Turkish Q layout it doesn't get ";" command at all. I don't expect you to put every layout known there of course, but it can be more customizable, maybe per key configuration or something like that.
  • ssernikk 1 day ago
    I'm curious how assets for this game were generated. You had to pass AI images through some pixel-aligning filter, right?

    I feel like AI-generated pixel art[0] is less noticeable than regular images... which upsets me, to be honest.

    [0] through this metod, not just "make it pixel art" appended to the prompt.

  • fcoury 1 day ago
    Would be awesome for a casual play if we could go straight to typing actual text.
  • charlesabarnes 1 day ago
    I didn't expect to finish the game with a character. Its pretty fun!
  • bardackx 18 hours ago
    there is no penalty for just smashing keys, i did not even tried to read what i was pressing
  • siva7 18 hours ago
    touch type? for what? do you still write code by hand?
  • mwojtera 1 day ago
    I like it! Can I test it on my kids?
    • 4lb3rn 1 day ago
      Don't fight your kids please. One day they become stronger than you are
  • SamLeBarbare 1 day ago
    keyboard layout plz...
    • Tepix 1 day ago
      there are a few (now) in the settings.
      • andrem 1 day ago
        A Dvorak one would be great too!
  • flyingmonkee 1 day ago
    very cool. controls could be a bit more easier.
  • AsDivyansh 1 day ago
    how much are you spending on servers?
  • m0op 1 day ago
    no ssl certificate
    • torumitch 1 day ago
      Thanks for flagging this. HTTPS appears valid from here (Let's encrypt free certificate). Could you share more details about the issue?
  • thepasch 1 day ago
    Quite frustrating how the "Next:" display keeps lying to you.
  • bitwize 1 day ago
    thanks i hate it

    very obviously slopped together, none of the whimsy of, say, the typing of the dead

    reminds me of those one-shot games i had to review for my ai evaluation work

    • makerofthings 10 hours ago
      Low effort AI slop is the future, didn't you get the memo?
    • arijanj 22 hours ago
      yep, welcome to the modern age
  • trippsydrippsy 1 day ago
    [dead]