eInk is in fact susceptible to aging, burn-in, and wear.
It's literally a mechanical device (well, I suppose, an electrostatic/fluidic device, but still, it is not solid state...fairly large particles have to physically move/rotate in a liquid layer), one that utilizes a voltage difference of up to 40v, too.
A color iEink screen even more sensitive because now you're not just dealing with flipping particles or making them move closer or further from the surface, you're doing it with four different particles. Similar to how SLC is more durable than TLC, which is more durable than QLC, etc.
I think most people don't realize that the cost for e-ink on a shelf versus paper is still way in the favor of paper, as you said. And that says nothing of the technical challenge that comes with adding that many devices to either an RF or IP network and ensuring that it works with existing, sometimes decades-old pricing systems. Then there's the legal challenges for displaying one price on the shelf but ringing another at the register - with paper, a human can indicate that the price label is updated, but with e-ink, there needs to be some other confirmation of change.
The cost is not in favor of paper and hasn't been for a decade or so. These devices have been in widespread use in Asia for a long time. Best Buy went to them a few years ago, Walmart is moving to them.
The devices are often optical, with overhead IR transmitters. The fact that you don't know that shows how little you know about the market and thus should not be talking about it.
RF is also used, yes - various protocols ranging from proprietary to bluetooth LE.
Even if only one price per second can be transmitted, that's 3600 items per hour, which means that in 24 hours, 86,400 items can be re-priced. You'd need several employees working non-stop to even hope to hit that rate.
As for the legal challenges they're able to point to logs as well as information on the digital display showing when it was last updated. Also, updates are not necessarily live - they can push out updated pricing info and then activate it at a specific time or via secondary command.
Get a similar sized IPS for $250 and you can use the rest to cover electricity use for the next 20 years at US avg price. That's assuming 24/7 but you can make it turn off if no one's looking or at night. Not sure what's the use case.
So make your own with an old monitor panel for a few hundred bucks?
And yeah: there is zero commercial demand for a product like this, it's about as niche as it gets while still existing. No normal person needs an e-ink display this big (because something this size is pretty much useless for anything but a digital poster, which regular TV/monitors can already do better, for cheaper), and the sizes folks do need (e.g. e-readers and passive displays) already have plenty on offer.
But, there are always individuals who want something like this. Not enough to make it a runaway commercial success, but enough to make it a boutique successful-enough-to-stick-around-for-a-while at least.
It's a 30 inch eink screen from a very small company based in the US. This isn't a million unit run from samsung, run by some EVP who buys out the entire factory's output six years in a row.
Sold out immediately anyway, I don't think there's much customer pressure driving down prices for these when they make like 400 and sell them to the richest people they can find.
For about same price you can get a Steam Fram- oh wait you can't, Valve also only made 400 of them lmao.
Since he deleted his blog, and scrubbed it all from wayback, here's an archive of some of the problematic things Ryan has written: https://thewritingsofryankculp.pages.dev/
What's the deal with e-paper and people being bad at have opinions? I personally got the Daylight Computer day one of pre-orders being open. Now they've gone anti-vax. I was about to order this device as well, but then I saw this. I still may order it, but this sucks. Funding this behavior feels ugly.
As another disappointed DC-1 owner (all the more disappointed because despite everything, I still love and use mine, too), I'm not entirely shocked that they went down the crunchy-granola-to-anti-vax rabbit hole. Looking back, their whole branding angle was always a little woowoo. I didn't think much of it, though, until after I'd already bought one and they sent out a user survey asking about my experience with the DC-1. One of the questions was whether the reduced exposure to blue light had enabled me to quit taking antidepressants(?!?).
They certainly won't get more money from me, but if/when my DC-1 ever dies (or when the apps that I need finally stop working on its ridiculously outdated version of Android) I'm not sure what I'll do to replace it. The most promising thing I've seen so far is the TCL NXTPAPER, which has an e-ink-ish mode, and it's a hell of a lot cheaper than anything comparable from Boox/reMarkable/etc.
Interesting, how does his politics affect the product/company? Or is it more the sense that you don't want to have relationships with people who have different political beliefs?
Go read some of what he's said. He sounds like some teenager you'd encounter playing Call of Duty. Someone with that sort of temperament shouldn't be the CEO of a banana stand and should be forced out by their board.
I have a use case for this. I want it. I can use it in my daily life. It's what I've been hoping for for years... But this price is crazy. I can't justify owning this at 1.2k. Maybe at 400,id even go for 500, which is a crazy amount of money for a wall display/calendar. But I'd justify the utility at that price.
This is a new J curve for product pricing that ive never seen before
5x the price of the next cheapest product is incredibly steep and with how the X released, I dont have a ton of confidence for the product even though i really want to.
If this was closer to $500 it would make sense
Also the wooden frame is entirely unneccesary and seems more like a personal project more so than a positive enhancement for customers.
Make it easily frameable for all types of frames instead of requiring a handmade wooden one that likely increases production costs
I mean, that's true of like most things. People buy things so that they don't have to make them themselves. This is the fundamental premise of markets.
i could also order a 31.5 inch E Ink Spectra 6 panel
and, if i'm being really dedicated, i could head on down to the beach with a shovel, some carbon, a heat source, a quartz crucible, a uv source, a laser printer, some hobby knives, a liter of sulfuric acid, and a flagrant disrespect for the EPA
then i could grab a couple of notebooks, and bootstrap my own isa, runtime, renderer, and a couple of banks of dip switches.
> Also the wooden frame is entirely unneccesary and seems more like a personal project more so than a positive enhancement for customers.
I mean.. the product seems to be pretty focused on being an aesthetic, customizable screen and not a utilitarian tech dashboard. In which case, it absolutely needs the wood frame to "fit in" to decor.
I have a second-hand Samsung Frame connected to an old laptop that periodically wakes up, generates a couple dozen images daily, and then transfers them to the Frame TV via the Samsung Frame’s WebSocket API. It automatically changes the picture every 30 minutes.
The "Art Mode" setting along with its matte finish makes it non-reflective, so it just acts like a nice little gallery on my wall. It’s using older models, mainly SDXL, so a lot of the pictures can be a little goofy and its been humming along for several years at this point.
I’d love to pick up one of these TRMNL devices and do something similar but the price at $1200 (soon to be $1300) gives me pause.
Not the GP, but I did a similar thing where an eink picture frame displays AI-generated landscapes with the weather being the same as the current weather/time of day as outside.
I just like the variation and didn't need to go source a bunch of actual images of the specific weather patterns.
Honestly, I would have the same reservations. Mine's an older model, but Samsung has only become more user-hostile as time has gone on.
That being said, I was able to pretty easily connect my Samsung Frame to the LAN and then block it at the router level from making outbound requests to the internet.
Mine is an old 2022 model so its not OLED - I measured it a while ago (43") and in art mode it was drawing down around ~35-40W on average about 5-6 bucks a month when left on continuously.
This looks dope but at that price is just a neat accessory for the wealthy. Is there a feasible route to it being about a tenth the price, like $150? Is it just a scale thing? You can get new dell monitors around that size for $200 or less.
It seems expensive because it is niche, and niche because it is expensive. At a dramatically lower price I think loads of people would love two or three of these around the house.
E-Ink yields are supposedly low at these sizes. But they also have patents, y’know. There are reflective/transflective LCDs, but they’re not quite the same.
I am not interested about art nor colour screen but if I could have my grafana monitoring refreshing every 10 sec that would be quite cool. They seem to have other products that are targeting this but I am confused about how the image should go from my browser to the device. You even have to pay extra for the "developer" feature that allows you to access the API (?!).
Slightly relevant but I was just researching a smaller eink-display to place in a hotel room for a client and I discovered the `ReTerminal E1001` - pretty cool if anyone is looking for smaller (7.5") hackable solution with mics and beep for $69.
I hope the prices of the larger displays come down a bit at some point and become more popular.
I’ve been using a couple of the ReTerminal displays and they’re great. I use the e1004 13” for a family calendar/schedule board. It comes framed and the battery lasts a month or two. It’s the best option I have found that’s not over a thousand dollars.
I recently started playing with a reTerminal E1003, the 10.3 inch monochrome version and I've been very happy with it.
$150 not bad at all for a reasonably high resolution (1404x1872) 10 inch e-ink panel with a touch screen.
Really easy setup for writing custom firmware (I've been using PlatformIO, C and LVGL) and just really solid hardware so far.
The only downside was that it took close to 2 months to get off backorder.
While looking into the available e-ink options I took a look at TRMNL's stuff as well but it turns out the TRMNL founder is a hardcore MAGA racist misogynist and I refuse to give money to such people.
Inky Impression has been popular lately. It's ~$275 on its own though. I am making a bird frame running fugleramme[0] and to purchase all of the materials (including RaspberryPi 5, power, frame, etc.) it's about $400 total.
Looks great! Love the wood frame. Would prefer it to be in a different aspect ratio tho, this ratio just says 'screen'.. but perhaps a e.g. 5:7 panel wouldn't be that easy to find?
I'm sure it's a high quality product, but given that "hacking" a random screen is just a Claude prompt these days, I think it's a hard sale. I think most consumers don't really care about the advantages of eInk versus a cheap display.
I really dislike the muted colors, soft spoken, quiet music, product videos that seem to be everywhere, talking about how "different" they are. Showing someone hand-carving into a piece of wood, talking about "made in the USA", like some third-generation craftsman with a beard and a cap. It all feels like artisanal firewood.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBb9O-aW4zI
This would be a heck of a lot more interesting if they'd worked with Modos on the display controller instead of just putting up with eink's glacial pace of, well, everything (development, improvement, actual image refresh on the panel). There's so much possible with the multipigment screens that's yet to be unlocked with better driver hardware and software.
For a product that's designed for static images where repaint speed isn't a major consideration, there's no excuse for putting up with eink's cruddy driverware at the cost of quality. Missed opportunity for differentiation.
I think it's considered cheap in it's class. It looks like a similarly sized InkPoster is 1,700. BLOOMIN8 has a 28.5" one that's on pre-order for $2,200.
Yeah the cheapest spectra 6 31.5” product I can find that is not just the bare panel is the Samsung emdx around $950. $1200 with a nice frame and better software support is reasonable to me.
haven't seen $140 for 13.3” spectra 6, can you share a link? we do already support those models (firmware + core app + oss servers) however, and i don’t like competition.
I would buy one at $1200 if the colors look good/rich in person and if you can change for a different frame. I have a feeling I'm going to be disappointed though - most of the pictures make it look like it has a bit of a washed out appearance.
At 31.5” and 1440p resolution this display has a PPI of 94. So it’s probably best viewed from a distance. I’m waiting for my 13” version (~150 PPI) to see if it makes sense to go bigger.
In the same vein is using the word "corporate" imagining that it conveys some meaning other than the user not understanding that one person corporations are a thing.
It conveys that the presentation of a business is different than a person, if the person is at all professional and adult. The number of employees is irrelevant.
A single person still wears different clothes and speaks with different language when acting as or on behalf of a business, than when at home in their pajamas passing a bong with their friends.
A business, like anyone, can certainly decide that it wants to portray this exact crafted image intentionally (rather than as the result of being dipshits) but equally potential cutomers or vendors can percieve that image however they want and make whatever judgements and conclusions about the business operators they want from it.
Anyway the single-personhood has no bearing. You're accusing someone of something only you did.
Looked interesting, until I saw that you had to pay an extra $20 for unlocking developer mode. At the $1300 price point, nickel-and-diming me for $20 was such a completely unneeded snap in the face, that i closed the purchase tab. Good luck I guess, but i will not be a customer, out of principle.
appreciate the feedback. our perspective is we bend over backwards for the dev community. priority support, 1:1 team chats in our dev-only Discord, manual plugin reviews by hand prior to publication, etc. but if you choose to self host, unnecessary.
I think the $20 is a reasonable filter for access to the dev team's energy and time, especially given the alternative of a vastly more expensive moderation and review burden if the floodgates were left open to everyone. HN won't much like it, but that's a normal bias in our community, so don't let us sway you by emotions alone.
Cheap ereaders such as xteink were made popular partly due to the unlocked firmware and custom roms for them. I guess this is a completely different target, but I would think double about it, you just need some guy with too much time and an llm agent to make something that goes popular on YouTube/reddit (...), but for 20$ he might not even want to try it
Better option is to just provide the dev support for all devs that need something for this device and have it included in the large price. The price splitting makes sense when you have $100 device, but not for $1000+ device.
Man how long and often do I need to get my hopes up?
You can't tell me that the company having the patent is so bad in making it cheaper and better so that the mass market would kick in?
Or is there 0 mass market for things like that?
Or is it really that expensive to make them bigger?
Lets see who wins in a few years: The price going down or my wallet
Continually for months is fine though. In fact it can passively display the same image forever without power or burn-in.
It's literally a mechanical device (well, I suppose, an electrostatic/fluidic device, but still, it is not solid state...fairly large particles have to physically move/rotate in a liquid layer), one that utilizes a voltage difference of up to 40v, too.
A color iEink screen even more sensitive because now you're not just dealing with flipping particles or making them move closer or further from the surface, you're doing it with four different particles. Similar to how SLC is more durable than TLC, which is more durable than QLC, etc.
There are lots of these use cases where e-ink displays would be perfect, but cannot be adopted.
The devices are often optical, with overhead IR transmitters. The fact that you don't know that shows how little you know about the market and thus should not be talking about it.
RF is also used, yes - various protocols ranging from proprietary to bluetooth LE.
Even if only one price per second can be transmitted, that's 3600 items per hour, which means that in 24 hours, 86,400 items can be re-priced. You'd need several employees working non-stop to even hope to hit that rate.
As for the legal challenges they're able to point to logs as well as information on the digital display showing when it was last updated. Also, updates are not necessarily live - they can push out updated pricing info and then activate it at a specific time or via secondary command.
This is the case in multiple chains in the UK.
And yeah: there is zero commercial demand for a product like this, it's about as niche as it gets while still existing. No normal person needs an e-ink display this big (because something this size is pretty much useless for anything but a digital poster, which regular TV/monitors can already do better, for cheaper), and the sizes folks do need (e.g. e-readers and passive displays) already have plenty on offer.
But, there are always individuals who want something like this. Not enough to make it a runaway commercial success, but enough to make it a boutique successful-enough-to-stick-around-for-a-while at least.
It's a niche product and e-ink has a monopoly on the technology. They can basically price it how they like.
I agree it would be really nice if it was like half the price though. Hard to justify at £1k.
?? It's 1.75x the price...
For about same price you can get a Steam Fram- oh wait you can't, Valve also only made 400 of them lmao.
Then the QA started to go down or the devices wouldn’t ship on time. On top of that, Ryan’s politics were a big turnoff.
I would not buy another device from this company.
Edit since this is being downvoted: https://casewrites.leaflet.pub/3mt5ap4xpxs2a?utm_source=blue...
This is not my blog post, but I am writing this comment on my DC-1.
They certainly won't get more money from me, but if/when my DC-1 ever dies (or when the apps that I need finally stop working on its ridiculously outdated version of Android) I'm not sure what I'll do to replace it. The most promising thing I've seen so far is the TCL NXTPAPER, which has an e-ink-ish mode, and it's a hell of a lot cheaper than anything comparable from Boox/reMarkable/etc.
"You disagree with me so you're opinions are BAD!" - Zambyte
Is a lot smaller, but the one on my wall works surprisingly well.
5x the price of the next cheapest product is incredibly steep and with how the X released, I dont have a ton of confidence for the product even though i really want to.
If this was closer to $500 it would make sense
Also the wooden frame is entirely unneccesary and seems more like a personal project more so than a positive enhancement for customers.
Make it easily frameable for all types of frames instead of requiring a handmade wooden one that likely increases production costs
waiting for some noname brands with this exact same product show up on Amazon soon
and, if i'm being really dedicated, i could head on down to the beach with a shovel, some carbon, a heat source, a quartz crucible, a uv source, a laser printer, some hobby knives, a liter of sulfuric acid, and a flagrant disrespect for the EPA
then i could grab a couple of notebooks, and bootstrap my own isa, runtime, renderer, and a couple of banks of dip switches.
you know... if you really care about that
I mean.. the product seems to be pretty focused on being an aesthetic, customizable screen and not a utilitarian tech dashboard. In which case, it absolutely needs the wood frame to "fit in" to decor.
The "Art Mode" setting along with its matte finish makes it non-reflective, so it just acts like a nice little gallery on my wall. It’s using older models, mainly SDXL, so a lot of the pictures can be a little goofy and its been humming along for several years at this point.
I’d love to pick up one of these TRMNL devices and do something similar but the price at $1200 (soon to be $1300) gives me pause.
https://imgpb.com/EZmRX
I don't mean this in a rude way, but you display AI images in your home as art? Do you just like the AI images better than art?
I'm trying to understand what this actually means.
I just like the variation and didn't need to go source a bunch of actual images of the specific weather patterns.
That being said, I was able to pretty easily connect my Samsung Frame to the LAN and then block it at the router level from making outbound requests to the internet.
It seems expensive because it is niche, and niche because it is expensive. At a dramatically lower price I think loads of people would love two or three of these around the house.
I hope the prices of the larger displays come down a bit at some point and become more popular.
$150 not bad at all for a reasonably high resolution (1404x1872) 10 inch e-ink panel with a touch screen.
Really easy setup for writing custom firmware (I've been using PlatformIO, C and LVGL) and just really solid hardware so far.
The only downside was that it took close to 2 months to get off backorder.
While looking into the available e-ink options I took a look at TRMNL's stuff as well but it turns out the TRMNL founder is a hardcore MAGA racist misogynist and I refuse to give money to such people.
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/inkanva/inkanva
Such as:
https://www.ntu.edu.sg/news/detail/near-invisible-ultrathin-...
So those complaining about price, it’s not bad tbh
0: https://github.com/arnegiacomo/fugleramme
https://inkposter.com/products/inkposter-affresco-31-5
Here's the display alone, more cheaper ($650):
https://www.cdw.com/product/samsung-em32dx-emdx-series-32-cl...
Full frame updates take 20-30 seconds.
Content needs to be dithered to the six fixed colors (no gradations) at the already fairly low 93 PPI.
Contrast is something like 25:1.
https://wesbos.com/hacking-smart-photo-frames
See https://github.com/Modos-Labs/Glider/blob/main/README.md#fas... for an old example of what they've managed to do with an old CMYW Gallery Palette panel (512 colors instead of 7), or https://www.eniacelec.com/pages/tickey for an actual recent product that's pushing 48 native colors on a spectra 6 panel.
For a product that's designed for static images where repaint speed isn't a major consideration, there's no excuse for putting up with eink's cruddy driverware at the cost of quality. Missed opportunity for differentiation.
What do you specifically mean? Are you Modos?
> for an old example of what they've managed to do with an old CMYW Gallery Palette panel (512 colors instead of 7)
"Though to be honest I hacked the right one a bit to display 512 colors opposed to the stock 7 colors".
There's only 4 pigments, CMYK in the panel. Dithering is "512 colors"?
> eink's cruddy driverware
What do you specifically mean?
I know e-ink is special, but man, the target market at the current pricing must be people with >100K in the bank or something.
Hope to see some competitors pop up with a better value play.
https://www.seeedstudio.com/reTerminal-E1004-p-6692.html
I actually ordered their 3.97" reTerminal Sticky (monochrome) for 50 bucks last week. Excited to mess with it, I've never had an ePaper anything.
Disclaimer: I'm CEO of Pimoroni and we make similar products in the UK: https://shop.pimoroni.com/products/inky-impression?variant=5...
https://www.seeedstudio.com/reTerminal-E1004-p-6692.html
Also, apparently Samsung's version uses the same Spectra 6 panel as well:
https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1963755-REG/samsung_e...
A single person still wears different clothes and speaks with different language when acting as or on behalf of a business, than when at home in their pajamas passing a bong with their friends.
A business, like anyone, can certainly decide that it wants to portray this exact crafted image intentionally (rather than as the result of being dipshits) but equally potential cutomers or vendors can percieve that image however they want and make whatever judgements and conclusions about the business operators they want from it.
Anyway the single-personhood has no bearing. You're accusing someone of something only you did.
the display itself is made in China using Chinese technologies