What made Steve Jobs great was that he would rather have Apple cannibalize its successful product lines than fall prey to a competitor. You can see this pattern with the iPod. The iPod disrupted itself many, many times. The iPod Mini then the iPod Nano. Then the iPod shuffle as the answer to the race ot the bottom.
The biggest moment was partnering with Motorola as phones started becoming more capable and flash memory got cheaper to bring music to phones, which was then the prelude to the iPhone.
The iPhone killed the iPod. Most companies would have never created the product, because it would have killed their golden goose, but Jobs did.
Just like he went all in on the iPad which had the potential to kill the cheap student Mac.
If Nvidia's next CEO is smart, they'd buy up a bunch of these companies that "burn" weights to silicon, make the process better, and then sell that as a service. Let it cannibalize the sales of their products. It's better for them to do it to themselves than their competitors.
Yes you're right but since he left Apple has become much more successful. Sure it isn't as innovative as it could be but still its #1 in pretty much everything consumer hardware. It isn't the most valuable company in the world for nothing.
If Jobs hadn’t rebuilt Apple after returning it wouldn’t be here today. Many seemed to agree it was over.
October 6, 1997: Michael Dell makes an incredibly bleak appraisal of Apple’s fortunes, uttering a quote that will become notorious. Asked what he would do with the struggling company, the founder of Dell Inc. says he would “shut it down and give the money back to the shareholders.”
I don't know how old you are but seriously, only the most fanatical Apple users were left for many years. What he is saying isn't particularly controversial.
Their contributions outside of the personal computing market is really what saved them overall. Sales were pretty flat until 2004, at which point their ipod devices really were cranking along and started pumping the overall brand.
(The switch to a nix system was great, but it didn't drive sales enough.) In my perspective, it wasn't until they left intel that their machines got significantly better, which is funny, because I respect the hell out of intel, but apple was right to focus on better performance per watt and less hot machines.
Two things saved Apple before we got into the 2000s: $150M from Microsoft [0] and the blue-and-white products (the iMac and the PowerMac G3).
Everything after that happens in the light of the absolute knockout success of the iMac, which got a staggering amount of good press and bought them so much earned media because it was such a product-placement-friendly device; as was the original iBook.
(My low key odd belief is that one of the biggest positives of that era for Apple was the Mac version of Outlook Express. I think we forget just how much easier the iMac made going onto the internet)
[0] you could argue that Apple was, in a way, too culturally important to fail at that moment; Microsoft invested (with non-voting stock) as a way to ameliorate some of their anti-trust circumstances, because the weakened state of Apple was perceived by the press and the world of politics to be partly a consequence of their behaviour.
Why do people insist on saying Apple isn't as innovative since Jobs died?
* Apple Watch
* Apple Pencil
* AirPods
* HomePod
* AirTag
* Vision Pro
* iPhone Duo
* Titan / self-driving (massive investment in advanced technology, despite not launching)
* Apple Pay
* Apple Silicon
* Touch ID
* Face ID
* ProMotion
* Metal
* Swift
* ...
Most of these are Apple versions of things that had already been done successfully elsewhere.
Apple did not invent or even popularize smart watches, fingerprint readers, Bluetooth earbuds, smart home hubs, VR/AR headsets, self driving, mobile payments, foldable phones, etc.
About 2/3rd of the Apple versions of these aren’t even the most popular in their category.
Apple silicon was the inevitable byproduct (IMHO) of Apple buying PA Semi in 2008 for a bargain price I might add. I think Steve deserves a lot of the credit for that one.
I'd say Tim's biggest successes were Apply Pay, the Apple Watch (although this was originally targeted as a luxury item instead of a health/fitness device), AirTags and probably AirPods. Apple Pencil seemed inevitable. Vision Pro? Um, AR is kinda dead. Duo? I think the jury is still out on this in terms of reliability. But we've had other folding phones for years.
I'm still mad Apple has largely abandoned Touch ID. I despise Face ID. Give me, the user, the option. Put a sensor on the back of the phone, you know like Samsung has been doing since the Galaxy ~S8.
Why do you insist on defending them? Even if you an employee, stockholder and decked out in Apple gear, you aren't gaining anything throwing yourself into battle for them at all. If other people don't agree with your take on Apple, so what they can suffer. Public opinion won't change until the media they consume suggests something else to them for a while in a subtle enough way they will believe themselves clever deducing it.
Are we measuring success by stock price or by revenue growth or some combination therein?
One might say years if the revenue growth under Tim actually came from the decisions made before Tim, by Steve. It's hard to delineate the two. Moreover, you normally extract profit by innovating less so you can focus on margins, but if you do it too much and for too long, your future gets murkier because you've abandoned the mantra that got you successful in the first place.
A classic example of this was Intel, where hubris and bean counters made it rich and then also are what basically killed it. Apple has a bigger moat, but it's not immune to the same sort of fall from grace. Microsoft will probably experience this sooner though, to be fair.
> would rather have Apple cannibalize its successful product lines than
I used to think this but don't think the claim holds up. The one instance that it happened was with the transition from iPod to iPhone, a bet on a higher margin product. Since then the Apple sandbagged iPad for Mac and Apple Watch for iPhone. Before then time and time again Apple hobbled perfectly good computers to maintain margin on higher cost products. The Low End Mac website sometimes referred to them as "Road Apples."
The main Apple product today is the ecosystem. Apple wants you to give them $X/mo, where X is more or less as much as you can afford, and ideally keeps going up over time.
They’re not letting the iPad cannibalize the Mac or the Watch cannibalize the iPhone because they want you to buy an iPad AND a Mac, a Watch AND a phone.
If there was a world where they could sell 20 million iPods a quarter, they’d bring back the iPod.
There aren't a bunch of these companies, and the TCO would be nightmarishly horrible. We go roughly 4 weeks between significant model releases at this point. Rest is just free-associating about Apple.
I think the ipod -> ipod mini is just natural upgrade. In both cases they bought out exclusive supply of tiny little harddrives for use in music players (you could still buy them for e.g. a windows CE sleeve like on the iPaq, they only bought exclusivity for dedicated music players). Once someone came out with a new tinier drive they didn't have exclusivity with them and if they didn't buy out exclusivity on it for the iPod mini they would have been destroyed by competitors releasing much smaller music players.
And they could outbid everyone else because of their premium brand, experience, and the margin they were getting.
Zune was able to get access to them with the Toshiba Gigabeat loophole by having Toshiba manufacture the Zune. The deal with Toshiba didn't cover stuff Toshiba manufactured. The smaller drive in the mini was made by Hitachi.
The iPod Mini to iPod Nano was the big strategic move. When they killed the Mini it was selling like hot cakes. Apple needed to get the cost of flash memory down and shifting the market to be flash paved the way for the iPhone, iPad, etc.
Apple also has the advantage that they can always grow down the market. The Neo is the perfect example of this. It's easier for Apple to sacrifice margin for market share than it is for a competitor to move upmarket.
As the author mentions, the biggest threat is from customers becoming competitors. The problem space is stabilizing and this allows the biggest buyers of GPUs to work with companies like broadcom to make their own chips. Thanks to agents, they can also spin up their own abstraction layers and debug tools. CUDA is becoming less relevant, and the rate at which that is happening is about to go parabolic.
Surely Nvidia won’t stand still and will continue to compete, but the margins will collapse along with volumes.
AMD will probably suffer less, relatively speaking. Their failure to invest in software finally seems to be paying off now that LLMs can pick up their slack. But the growth currently priced in to their stock will never materialize and they’ll be seen as arriving just in time for the lights to go out.
> CUDA is becoming less relevant, and the rate at which that is happening is about to go parabolic.
CUDA is the 'open' standard that exists today, has market/mind share, and doesn't lock you into a vendor. Look at google to see how difficult it is to make a new chip and surrounding system.
Still, Nvida should work on making the generation of chips and languages that come after CUDA.
Yup. There are so many layers the majority doesnt interact with, so they focus on what they know. The current stack has probably 10-12 layers. And NVIDIA touches more layers than anyone else.
Yeah and that’s cool but the large labs don’t need open standards. They are big enough and well funded enough to have their own in-house solutions (and they already have them). They haven’t significantly cut their Nvidia purchases yet though.
True, but leadership changes, how it happened, and that new leadership's affiliations, are giving my group heavy re-thought on what future nvidia plays in our compute needs. The only country we trust less than China is Israel, and this Nvidia coup has not exactly been reassuring. The reason we focus local models is that exact affiliation problem providers with good models have. We're already investigating AMD and how we can transition, hopefully sooner rather than later given israel's history of slipping malware into absolutly everything.
>As the author mentions, the biggest threat is from customers becoming competitors.
Maybe in the long term. The biggest threat in the short term is Nvidia's exposure to the data center bubble, which was already showing signs of popping before Jensen's departure. Given Nvidia's role as a key investment bank in the AI trade, making and brokering circular financing deals around data centers, his departure could hasten the data center collapse if the company starts backing away from its key financing role.
I'm kinda surprised at how many people on this thread think you can now vibecode a GPU and compete with NVidia, basically. This is a wildly optimistic view of AI's capabilities. NVidia has several important moats and a huge lead in this space. That's not going to disappear anytime soon. It has expertise in chip design, the volume relationship with TSMC and the relationship with HBM producers.
I do agree CUDA is becoming less relevant though.
There are two companies I'd be most concerned about if I were NVidia's CEO:
1. Apple. It's huge and has a long history at this point of making very efficient chips that use a shared memory pool. This defeats NVidia's tactic of aggressive market segmentation by the amount of VRAM. You can buy a Mac Studio with 256GB of RAM (well, you have to wait until March currently) for ~$11k. That's a lot cheaper than a single RTX 6000 Pro; and
2. Google. They currently buy or rent a lot of GPU capacity from SpaceX and others as well as make their own data centers. But they also have their own TPUs that they've been developing for years. I would be shocked if they've not investing billions into ramping up that program so they can use homegrown chips for AI. Google is still the best at building their own data centers and their own networking is industry-leading (IMHO).
The timing of the WH dropping this makes me suspect Kushner types angling to tank stock, make a lot of bag holders, buy it all up with Saudi or some other country's help
Dylan Ratigan went on that rant a decade ago about it being a mathematical fact American wealth was being extracted through sale of all these corps and offshoring
We are to be serfs of royalty, religious cranks, and the rest of the non-contributor orator class
A quick prompt to ChatGPT estimates that a B300 should cost around 6-10k in a mature market given typical CPU industry/silicon economics. NVidia has a massive margin for a semi-conductor firm, it would not be surprising to learn that AI is much cheaper than we currently estimate when that margin is removed.
Why do you think custom chips means they'll stop buying GPUs not just use more of everything? That's what I saw when AMD got competitive with Intel and arm showed up.
Power is the bottleneck. If big labs need to use their more efficient, in-house solutions then they will. These companies are big enough to create their own weather, so to speak.
Serious question: putting aside the whole "spy" thing given there are doubts around the truth of that matter, would this have been as big a deal if he wasn't married? What if it turns out he has an open marriage? It's an interesting reflection of society and the morals we hold public and powerful people to that if he was a single man then I doubt anyone would care at all about this.
Sort of doesn’t matter if she is a full time asset of the Chinese security services, or part time. The evidence is pretty clear that she was running a GPU smuggling operation to get around US export controls, and the question is, how much was JH helping?
You can't put aside the Chinese spy thing, it is the strongest lever to oust him. It has been used against tiktok's Singaporean CEO, it has been used against many researchers.
The amount of China paranoia at the top is crazy, and using it as a weapon is very effective, because it doesn't need presenting hard evidence in court.
It would have been over when the second affair came out with a direct report. The liability is beyond acceptable for a board. Everyone passed up for a promotion could sue.
Idk, that explanation rings kinda hollow for me. Musk is trying to reproduce with at least one exec from each of his companies and it doesn't seem to be an issue- I think at some of his corps the board could theoretically take action if they wanted to
We probably won't know for certain until the shareholder lawsuits drag it into the eyes of the public, but it's also worth keeping in mind that he was fired only after the second instance of infidelity came to light. The company came to his defense in the first. It's unlikely that they'd excuse one instance but not two, which suggests that his firing might be because he lied about there not being any other relationships. A CEO which directly lies to the board is liable to piss off said board.
Jensen is a big part of the Nvidia brand. Surely the board isn't that stupid to risk losing the brand because of adultery? Why didn't Jensen fight to keep his job? There has to be something we do not know...
I don't know why people here can't accept that sleeping with a subordinate is a fireable offense. It almost certainly violates Nvidia policy and it risks lawsuits. Once that came out, the board pretty much had to fire him. In fact, I think there'd likely be a shareholder lawsuit against the board if they didn't fire him.
Also, sleeping with an executive of a customer reflects very poor judgment, even more so when the customer can be somewhat credibly be accused of export violations. Then, on top of that, he sleeps with a subordinate. A day later, it seems there might be a second employee. This isn't like he's sleeping with two or three random women that aren't his wife, it's employees and customers. It would be hard to find worse choices. He's tarnished his own brand. The Nvidia board did the right thing. (Also, if you have a bus factor of 1, your first priority is fixing that.)
Hmm, I don't know but same thing doesn't seem to apply to Elon Musk for some reason. The current situation looks like a regime change to me. It started with Spy narrative, now, they are saying she mightn't be a spy.
Who are “they”? The U.S. intelligence apparatus thought she was a spy and briefed Trump about this multiple times. Trump diverted AF1 to pick up Jensen in Alaska and bring him to Beijing for the summit _after Rubio briefed him during the flight about Jensen being compromised_.
But that will be good for the rest of the industry. Nvidia, having such a huge lead over the competition, was making it hard for them to flourish. With Nvidia gone, AMD will have a chance, OpenAI will develop its Jalapeno, Google might find more customers for its TPUs, Amazon could revive their AI chips, etc, etc. Over the long run, I think we will all benefit. With the exception of the Nvidia shareholders, for sure, but they are most likely diversified anyway, so they won't lose their shirt.
That doesn’t sound like a benefit to me, since what you’re describing is only reduced competition in GPUs that are sold publicly. No one can buy a TPU or a Jalapeño or Inferentia, etc., and that is bad.
I don’t like Nvidia, but I hate private chips far more.
Intel and AMD sell to the public. Their GPUs are not competitive with Nvidia's, but from their point of view investing in that business had a Catch 22 problem. Jensen Huang just solved that problem for them.
I don't know how people can say this with a straight face. Nvidia could cut off every customer except the US government, and they'd probably be able to maintain CUDA for decades. They occupy a niche that nobody can evict them from.
AMD, Apple, Intel and the rest of those companies have had their opportunity to compete, and they've steered away from GPGPU every time. The big bet on TPUs/ASICs isn't a bad one, but it also doesn't put them in direct competition with the parallel compute offerings that Nvidia sells to customers. Even if Nvidia enters maintenance mode with a series of bad CEOs, there will be sufficient interest in keeping them afloat for the foreseeable future.
I'd also say, NVIDIA will crash and burn. Unless they get Jensen back. It is an organization that was optimized for 33 years around Jensen. Re-optimizing it around another CEO, who is not the Founder, at this point in time, would likely result in multiple catastrophic failures.
I'd say the winners would be: lawyers, possibly China, possibly OpenAI or Anthropic, if they'd play their cards right and manage to convince the investors that as Founders-CEO companies they'll be able to compete building silicon.
Sure, but can this be done on a dime and without casualties, and in such a forceful way?
All it takes is a tiny bit of distraction, you get outages like Outlook, FAA, or this recent event with "Microsoft 365 outage leads to chlorine gas poisoning of 15 hotel guests (wdr.de)" ...
Where does the narrative that "once a founder leaves, innovation dies" come from? Does the data support this theory?
Anecdotally, you can look at Apple, Msft, Google, Disney, Walmart, and any number of companies that have been successful over many decades to question this theory. I'm sure there's a long list of companies that have slowly died after founder exits as well.
Is there actually a correlation between innovation and whether the CEO happens to be a founder?
I think the founder can maintain the purity of vision. Innovation may still exist, but may stray from the original goals or intent of the founder, for better or worse.
That isn't to say founders can't lose their way, but things tend to get lost in translation when someone else is in charge. Priorities shift and details that may have appeared small, yet vitally important to the founder, get dismissed when they are no longer there to hold the line on the little things.
Right. My assumption is that the next leader just has their own "do not cross" lines to hold. They have their own vision. Not necessarily better or worse, but certainly different.
Again though: in the aggregate, It's not obvious to me that there's any strong correlation between an organizations ability to innovate and whether they are founder-run or not.
Jensen Huang is not coming back. For the board to invite him to return after being on notice that he may have committed a felony on the company’s behalf would constitute gross negligence, and possibly even criminal conspiracy. I guarantee the company’s lawyers are like “fuck no.”
Duress: Same reason why we don't think witches burned at the stake after confessing ever had orgies with Satan. Someone starts yanking your nails off with pliers, you tend to tell them what you think they want to hear, Jensen's family and home life being targeted its a similar effect. In the law that's called being in a state of duress.
But the default assumption is that I'm not a spy, you're not a spy, she's not a spy.
China's government also made it illegal to import nvidia hardware, there's 600k H200s (!) stuck in a warehouse in Hong Kong right now[1]. So it's at the very least a little weird that a Chinese government spy would be breaking Chinese law all day long as her day job.
> But the default assumption is that I'm not a spy, you're not a spy, she's not a spy.
That’s a very convenient default that benefits spycraft.
I have no idea whether Alice Huang is a Chinese spy or not; we may never know. Regardless, Jensen Huang may have broken the law by using the Singaporean front company for whom she allegedly worked to funnel export-restricted chips to China. If she was also a Chinese spy that he was also schtupping, that would have been frosting on the cake.
The story you linked to says “Approximately 600,000 Nvidia H200 chips destined for mainland China are currently being held in Hong Kong, awaiting import approval from the Chinese government.” There’s no mention that China makes the importation unlawful, and it would be an odd thing to say if it were. Do you have a trustworthy source that says it is illegal under Chinese law to import them?
> That’s a very convenient default that benefits spycraft.
There's 1.4 billion Chinese. Let's say 50-100 million of them have decent English. You gonna assume every Chinese you meet is a spy? Can we examine why everyone just said "oh yeah of course she's a spy" based on zero evidence and require evidence that she's not?
> Do you have a trustworthy source that says it is illegal under Chinese law to import them?
> You gonna assume every Chinese you meet is a spy?
Of course not. I leave that determination to subject matter experts, based on the available evidence, like a good engineer should. We may never know whether she is for sure. I think “maybe” is a perfectly reasonable position to hold.
> Here's a link from when the ban went into place earlier this year, it made news at the time. It appears to be more of a "policy" thing than a "law" thing.
Do we know whether this position was still held as of Q3 this year? This story was from back in January.
Based on 600k H200s being stuck in Hong Kong, it appears the policy is still in effect. That's a lot of money to be parked in a warehouse.
And, no, "maybe" is an extremely paranoid assumption to hold about any random Chinese person. The % of people in the world who are spies is really small. It says something about the overall media environment that people just uncritically go with "sure, spy" on zero evidence.
You understand that the word “maybe” is not identical to “probably,” “likely,” or “certainly,” right? They are different words in the English language with different meanings. Is English your first language?
You also realize that Alice Huang isn’t just some Chinese rando who happens to speak English, right?
You seem awfully defensive. Perhaps we should wonder why.
The latter, as reported so far, does not begin to scratch the surface of the creepiness of high-profile cases we have seen in the Valley or elsewhere. If all the dirt they have on him after 33 years is this, that makes him almost a saint by Silicon Valley, Wall Street, DC, and Catholic Church standards.
Re the former, it seems to me to whatever degree the sales to [alleged] "foreign agent" is conducted, it has been with with knowledge and at least implicit consent of at least part of the US Government (Bessent was pointing fingers at Lutnick), so it is more of a policy disagreement among factions on how best they should conduct their China Policy, which is frankly not a clear-cut case, and reasonable people can and have debated on it. Does not appear to be some overtly rogue or hidden treasonous conduct.
Please walk me through it. What makes the first three known affairs tolerable, but then a hypothetical fourth affair unacceptable?
In my mind, when a person betrays their own partner, I have no reason to place any trust in them. Not in their judgement, not in their character.
As a former employee that had a rather positive view of the man, I was massively disappointed in the revelations. If I was still at NVidia, I would not want him back; NVidia has lots of excellent managers that can replace him.
These traits might be important if your goal was to marry a person. But I'm pretty sure the track record with NVidia from the very start speaks for itself plenty.
Both Microsoft and Apple, under leaders who supposedly have "no vision", have multiplied their market caps.
No one is coming for these companies' lunch and no one is coming for Nvidia's either. To do that now you need to disrupt an entire ecosystem. It is therefore not relevant in 2026 whether you invent. All you need to do in 2026 is get some market power and squeeze.
This author is writing either from a 2015 time bubble or else writing wishfully. Because what they say ignores where the capital and market share has flowed for the sake of an argument that used to be true and that we all wish still was true.
Nvidia's situation is very different by the way - not for the reason you think; its because they didn't get to prepare. If they fall from grace it'll be that, not some overwrought visionary/execution CEO thing.
CEO's aren't pharaohs or god kings, lets stop treating them that way - it's sick
They should endure the same kind of professional and legal consequences anyone else would for the bad things they do. No one is too big to fail or face the music
There must be something else going on behind the scenes for this, the 11 million dollar Nvidia GPU heist, microsoft doing the windows update to itself & the FAA shitting the bed all one after another (please its not the Chinese sweating bullets as they are facing internal issues they don't publish in the US to keep you all working away in fear of the red, paper menace their economy is looking more sickly that Nvidia).
Crazy, honestly low-key horrifying that a company worth 8% of the Dow Jones lost 10% of its value over the CEO having an affair...
Comparing Tim Cook to Balmer is laughable. Cook is generally regarded as one of the best CEOs in history. Balmer is Bill Gates skeezy friend who got to be in charge for a bit.
Balmer was the CEO of Microsoft for 14 years, Tim Cook 15. Balmer missed the mobile transition but did relatively well on the cloud (Azure and subscriptions) and gaming.
Balmer also missed on the Internet, multi-year IE6 stagnation was absolutely on purpose. He also destroyed the internal structure of Microsoft ( https://i.insider.com/50a25c5b69bedd0c7e000000?width=696&for... ), pitting different teams against each other.
it's the nature of technology that we'll have put some truly loathsome ceos on a pedestal, and for all we know we're living with the results of their embarassing failures but are just blind to what better men could've done with those opportunities
Every large company is constantly hammered by lawsuits. Surely the EU will determine Jensen didn't have the proper GDPR paperwork in place before sleeping with his side pieces. Defending lawsuits is just a cost of doing business.
Jensen Huang, really innovated that GPU pipe from Malaysia to China to Russia. Say what you want about Steve Jobs, but he wasn't hounded for innovation in skirting export restrictions, channel stuffing and potentially war-crimes[1].
Huang: "The microprocessor will be dedicated to other things like artificial intelligence. That trend is helpful to us. It's a trend that's inevitable."
yeah that's right, quasi-criminal loser gives public interview saying 'artificial intelligence is none of our business, and moving even further in that direction. it is inevitable'
Read the article, he was talking about gaming (in particular the Xbox) and running AI on CPU cores while most of the game processing would be on the GPU.
It's 3 years prior to the release of CUDA so it's probably around this time they were working out how to make the GPU much more programmable and what it could be used for.
The biggest moment was partnering with Motorola as phones started becoming more capable and flash memory got cheaper to bring music to phones, which was then the prelude to the iPhone.
The iPhone killed the iPod. Most companies would have never created the product, because it would have killed their golden goose, but Jobs did.
Just like he went all in on the iPad which had the potential to kill the cheap student Mac.
If Nvidia's next CEO is smart, they'd buy up a bunch of these companies that "burn" weights to silicon, make the process better, and then sell that as a service. Let it cannibalize the sales of their products. It's better for them to do it to themselves than their competitors.
October 6, 1997: Michael Dell makes an incredibly bleak appraisal of Apple’s fortunes, uttering a quote that will become notorious. Asked what he would do with the struggling company, the founder of Dell Inc. says he would “shut it down and give the money back to the shareholders.”
Their contributions outside of the personal computing market is really what saved them overall. Sales were pretty flat until 2004, at which point their ipod devices really were cranking along and started pumping the overall brand.
(The switch to a nix system was great, but it didn't drive sales enough.) In my perspective, it wasn't until they left intel that their machines got significantly better, which is funny, because I respect the hell out of intel, but apple was right to focus on better performance per watt and less hot machines.
Everything after that happens in the light of the absolute knockout success of the iMac, which got a staggering amount of good press and bought them so much earned media because it was such a product-placement-friendly device; as was the original iBook.
(My low key odd belief is that one of the biggest positives of that era for Apple was the Mac version of Outlook Express. I think we forget just how much easier the iMac made going onto the internet)
[0] you could argue that Apple was, in a way, too culturally important to fail at that moment; Microsoft invested (with non-voting stock) as a way to ameliorate some of their anti-trust circumstances, because the weakened state of Apple was perceived by the press and the world of politics to be partly a consequence of their behaviour.
Apple did not invent or even popularize smart watches, fingerprint readers, Bluetooth earbuds, smart home hubs, VR/AR headsets, self driving, mobile payments, foldable phones, etc.
About 2/3rd of the Apple versions of these aren’t even the most popular in their category.
iPhone is maybe the only one that seemed wholly novel.
I'd say Tim's biggest successes were Apply Pay, the Apple Watch (although this was originally targeted as a luxury item instead of a health/fitness device), AirTags and probably AirPods. Apple Pencil seemed inevitable. Vision Pro? Um, AR is kinda dead. Duo? I think the jury is still out on this in terms of reliability. But we've had other folding phones for years.
I'm still mad Apple has largely abandoned Touch ID. I despise Face ID. Give me, the user, the option. Put a sensor on the back of the phone, you know like Samsung has been doing since the Galaxy ~S8.
Apple Pencil: 4 years after S Pen
HomePod: 4 years after Alexa
Vision Pro: 5 years after Oculus Quest
iPhone Duo: 7 years after Z Fold
You can say the Apple ones are better than the stuffs they copied from in whatever fanatical metrics you use, but those aren't evidence of innovation.
One might say years if the revenue growth under Tim actually came from the decisions made before Tim, by Steve. It's hard to delineate the two. Moreover, you normally extract profit by innovating less so you can focus on margins, but if you do it too much and for too long, your future gets murkier because you've abandoned the mantra that got you successful in the first place.
A classic example of this was Intel, where hubris and bean counters made it rich and then also are what basically killed it. Apple has a bigger moat, but it's not immune to the same sort of fall from grace. Microsoft will probably experience this sooner though, to be fair.
I used to think this but don't think the claim holds up. The one instance that it happened was with the transition from iPod to iPhone, a bet on a higher margin product. Since then the Apple sandbagged iPad for Mac and Apple Watch for iPhone. Before then time and time again Apple hobbled perfectly good computers to maintain margin on higher cost products. The Low End Mac website sometimes referred to them as "Road Apples."
They’re not letting the iPad cannibalize the Mac or the Watch cannibalize the iPhone because they want you to buy an iPad AND a Mac, a Watch AND a phone.
If there was a world where they could sell 20 million iPods a quarter, they’d bring back the iPod.
And they could outbid everyone else because of their premium brand, experience, and the margin they were getting.
Zune was able to get access to them with the Toshiba Gigabeat loophole by having Toshiba manufacture the Zune. The deal with Toshiba didn't cover stuff Toshiba manufactured. The smaller drive in the mini was made by Hitachi.
Apple also has the advantage that they can always grow down the market. The Neo is the perfect example of this. It's easier for Apple to sacrifice margin for market share than it is for a competitor to move upmarket.
Surely Nvidia won’t stand still and will continue to compete, but the margins will collapse along with volumes.
AMD will probably suffer less, relatively speaking. Their failure to invest in software finally seems to be paying off now that LLMs can pick up their slack. But the growth currently priced in to their stock will never materialize and they’ll be seen as arriving just in time for the lights to go out.
CUDA is the 'open' standard that exists today, has market/mind share, and doesn't lock you into a vendor. Look at google to see how difficult it is to make a new chip and surrounding system.
Still, Nvida should work on making the generation of chips and languages that come after CUDA.
1. Physical infrastructure - power, cooling, network fabric, chip fabrication
2. Chips
3. Low level sw - CUDA/ROCm/Metal/XLA etc
4. Kernels - cuBLAS, cuDNN, FlashAttention, FlashInfer, Triton, llama.cpp
5. Kernel gen/optimization - MLIR, TVM, TensorRT
6. ML frameworks pytorch, jax, tensorslow
7. Models - Llama, Qwen, Claude, GPT, Gemini
8. More tuning - vLLM, SGLang, TensorRT-LLM, DeepSpeed, Megatron-LM
9. API/SDK/Platform
10. Apps/Agents/Pipelines/Orchestration etc
It's nice to see companies like Apple adding CUDA support in their own way.
The thing that increasingly intrigues me is how long it might take AI-assisted development to explore what else might be possible in the space.
Maybe in the long term. The biggest threat in the short term is Nvidia's exposure to the data center bubble, which was already showing signs of popping before Jensen's departure. Given Nvidia's role as a key investment bank in the AI trade, making and brokering circular financing deals around data centers, his departure could hasten the data center collapse if the company starts backing away from its key financing role.
I do agree CUDA is becoming less relevant though.
There are two companies I'd be most concerned about if I were NVidia's CEO:
1. Apple. It's huge and has a long history at this point of making very efficient chips that use a shared memory pool. This defeats NVidia's tactic of aggressive market segmentation by the amount of VRAM. You can buy a Mac Studio with 256GB of RAM (well, you have to wait until March currently) for ~$11k. That's a lot cheaper than a single RTX 6000 Pro; and
2. Google. They currently buy or rent a lot of GPU capacity from SpaceX and others as well as make their own data centers. But they also have their own TPUs that they've been developing for years. I would be shocked if they've not investing billions into ramping up that program so they can use homegrown chips for AI. Google is still the best at building their own data centers and their own networking is industry-leading (IMHO).
Dylan Ratigan went on that rant a decade ago about it being a mathematical fact American wealth was being extracted through sale of all these corps and offshoring
We are to be serfs of royalty, religious cranks, and the rest of the non-contributor orator class
The amount of China paranoia at the top is crazy, and using it as a weapon is very effective, because it doesn't need presenting hard evidence in court.
The affair w/ a possible spy is just what exposed it.
Also, sleeping with an executive of a customer reflects very poor judgment, even more so when the customer can be somewhat credibly be accused of export violations. Then, on top of that, he sleeps with a subordinate. A day later, it seems there might be a second employee. This isn't like he's sleeping with two or three random women that aren't his wife, it's employees and customers. It would be hard to find worse choices. He's tarnished his own brand. The Nvidia board did the right thing. (Also, if you have a bus factor of 1, your first priority is fixing that.)
But that will be good for the rest of the industry. Nvidia, having such a huge lead over the competition, was making it hard for them to flourish. With Nvidia gone, AMD will have a chance, OpenAI will develop its Jalapeno, Google might find more customers for its TPUs, Amazon could revive their AI chips, etc, etc. Over the long run, I think we will all benefit. With the exception of the Nvidia shareholders, for sure, but they are most likely diversified anyway, so they won't lose their shirt.
I don’t like Nvidia, but I hate private chips far more.
CUDA's big selling point is that your cheap 15W Tegra board will have broadly comparable compute capabilities to a server rack from the time.
AMD, Apple, Intel and the rest of those companies have had their opportunity to compete, and they've steered away from GPGPU every time. The big bet on TPUs/ASICs isn't a bad one, but it also doesn't put them in direct competition with the parallel compute offerings that Nvidia sells to customers. Even if Nvidia enters maintenance mode with a series of bad CEOs, there will be sufficient interest in keeping them afloat for the foreseeable future.
I'd say the winners would be: lawyers, possibly China, possibly OpenAI or Anthropic, if they'd play their cards right and manage to convince the investors that as Founders-CEO companies they'll be able to compete building silicon.
All it takes is a tiny bit of distraction, you get outages like Outlook, FAA, or this recent event with "Microsoft 365 outage leads to chlorine gas poisoning of 15 hotel guests (wdr.de)" ...
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50509411
Anecdotally, you can look at Apple, Msft, Google, Disney, Walmart, and any number of companies that have been successful over many decades to question this theory. I'm sure there's a long list of companies that have slowly died after founder exits as well.
Is there actually a correlation between innovation and whether the CEO happens to be a founder?
That isn't to say founders can't lose their way, but things tend to get lost in translation when someone else is in charge. Priorities shift and details that may have appeared small, yet vitally important to the founder, get dismissed when they are no longer there to hold the line on the little things.
Again though: in the aggregate, It's not obvious to me that there's any strong correlation between an organizations ability to innovate and whether they are founder-run or not.
Disney absolutely struggled in the time after Walt died.
https://wallhop.io/https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/14/techno...
https://edition.cnn.com/2026/11/12/politics/alice-huang-us-i...
https://www.reuters.com/world/china/us-justice-department-ha...
The details on original WSJ article has fake information, as confirmed by Singapore govt
https://www.mha.gov.sg/media-room/newsroom/clarification-sta...
China's government also made it illegal to import nvidia hardware, there's 600k H200s (!) stuck in a warehouse in Hong Kong right now[1]. So it's at the very least a little weird that a Chinese government spy would be breaking Chinese law all day long as her day job.
[1]https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/almost-600000-nvi...
That’s a very convenient default that benefits spycraft.
I have no idea whether Alice Huang is a Chinese spy or not; we may never know. Regardless, Jensen Huang may have broken the law by using the Singaporean front company for whom she allegedly worked to funnel export-restricted chips to China. If she was also a Chinese spy that he was also schtupping, that would have been frosting on the cake.
The story you linked to says “Approximately 600,000 Nvidia H200 chips destined for mainland China are currently being held in Hong Kong, awaiting import approval from the Chinese government.” There’s no mention that China makes the importation unlawful, and it would be an odd thing to say if it were. Do you have a trustworthy source that says it is illegal under Chinese law to import them?
There's 1.4 billion Chinese. Let's say 50-100 million of them have decent English. You gonna assume every Chinese you meet is a spy? Can we examine why everyone just said "oh yeah of course she's a spy" based on zero evidence and require evidence that she's not?
> Do you have a trustworthy source that says it is illegal under Chinese law to import them?
Here's a link from when the ban went into place earlier this year, it made news at the time. It appears to be more of a "policy" thing than a "law" thing. https://www.reuters.com/world/china/chinas-customs-agents-to...
Of course not. I leave that determination to subject matter experts, based on the available evidence, like a good engineer should. We may never know whether she is for sure. I think “maybe” is a perfectly reasonable position to hold.
> Here's a link from when the ban went into place earlier this year, it made news at the time. It appears to be more of a "policy" thing than a "law" thing.
Do we know whether this position was still held as of Q3 this year? This story was from back in January.
And, no, "maybe" is an extremely paranoid assumption to hold about any random Chinese person. The % of people in the world who are spies is really small. It says something about the overall media environment that people just uncritically go with "sure, spy" on zero evidence.
You also realize that Alice Huang isn’t just some Chinese rando who happens to speak English, right?
You seem awfully defensive. Perhaps we should wonder why.
The latter, as reported so far, does not begin to scratch the surface of the creepiness of high-profile cases we have seen in the Valley or elsewhere. If all the dirt they have on him after 33 years is this, that makes him almost a saint by Silicon Valley, Wall Street, DC, and Catholic Church standards.
Re the former, it seems to me to whatever degree the sales to [alleged] "foreign agent" is conducted, it has been with with knowledge and at least implicit consent of at least part of the US Government (Bessent was pointing fingers at Lutnick), so it is more of a policy disagreement among factions on how best they should conduct their China Policy, which is frankly not a clear-cut case, and reasonable people can and have debated on it. Does not appear to be some overtly rogue or hidden treasonous conduct.
Please walk me through it. What makes the first three known affairs tolerable, but then a hypothetical fourth affair unacceptable?
In my mind, when a person betrays their own partner, I have no reason to place any trust in them. Not in their judgement, not in their character.
As a former employee that had a rather positive view of the man, I was massively disappointed in the revelations. If I was still at NVidia, I would not want him back; NVidia has lots of excellent managers that can replace him.
the spy thing is a rumor. if it's substantiated sure, kick him out. if not, he deserves to be ceo. you should want your ceo to be someone who fucks
edit: dont downvote me, challenge me on my opinion!!!
He’s coming back.
No one is coming for these companies' lunch and no one is coming for Nvidia's either. To do that now you need to disrupt an entire ecosystem. It is therefore not relevant in 2026 whether you invent. All you need to do in 2026 is get some market power and squeeze.
This author is writing either from a 2015 time bubble or else writing wishfully. Because what they say ignores where the capital and market share has flowed for the sake of an argument that used to be true and that we all wish still was true.
Nvidia's situation is very different by the way - not for the reason you think; its because they didn't get to prepare. If they fall from grace it'll be that, not some overwrought visionary/execution CEO thing.
CEO's aren't pharaohs or god kings, lets stop treating them that way - it's sick
They should endure the same kind of professional and legal consequences anyone else would for the bad things they do. No one is too big to fail or face the music
Crazy, honestly low-key horrifying that a company worth 8% of the Dow Jones lost 10% of its value over the CEO having an affair...
And let's not forget Windows Vista.
[1]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YYU_geUwQoA
For embargo circumvention and smuggling, hopefully for price fixing as well.
https://web.archive.org/web/20031227062048/http://www.wired....
Huang: "The microprocessor will be dedicated to other things like artificial intelligence. That trend is helpful to us. It's a trend that's inevitable."
yeah that's right, quasi-criminal loser gives public interview saying 'artificial intelligence is none of our business, and moving even further in that direction. it is inevitable'
what a disgusting, revisionist take.
It's 3 years prior to the release of CUDA so it's probably around this time they were working out how to make the GPU much more programmable and what it could be used for.