12 comments

  • sschueller 15 minutes ago
    > Based on the available data, the percentage of the U.S. population that can realistically achieve FIRE (Financial Independence, Retire Early) is very small, likely less than 1% to 3%. This figure represents those who can both meet the strict financial criteria and successfully execute the plan to retire decades before the traditional age.

    According to Gallup polling, only 1% of Americans in their early 40s are retired, and just 6% of those in their early 50s have left the workforce. [1]

    Nice if you can do it. Most of us will never be able to.

    [1] https://www.investopedia.com/what-percentage-of-people-achie...

  • fishtoaster 39 minutes ago
    If you like this, I highly recommend https://projectionlab.com/ for scenario-modeling your future income and retirement.

    It's been discussed here a number of times and I've been a happy customer for years.

    https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36849502 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26969173

    • Espressosaurus 23 minutes ago
      I'll second that. I tried the trial for a few months then started paying money for it. At $100/year I've found it useful for modeling and gaming out different scenarios for retirement thresholds.

      Nothing's certain, but if you like to play with data and you don't want to build the whole damn thing yourself, it's useful.

      Still waiting for them to get support for options.

  • siliconc0w 46 minutes ago
    Don't forget the unbounded liability that is the US healthcare system!
    • dyzone 33 minutes ago
      Don't forget the unbounded liability that is the human condition!
      • ceasesurthinko 18 minutes ago
        Don’t forget the unbounded liability of AGI: your job disappears before you can accumulate the capital you need. On the bright side, you’re retired. Really simplifies the spreadsheet.
        • kuerbel 3 minutes ago
          Don't forget the unbounded liability of apocalypse: society implodes and your money is worthless. On the bright side, you might have invested in Nuka Cola.
  • vincnetas 8 minutes ago
    "How long do i have to work, until i can force others to work for me"

    or alternative "... until i have saved up enough to last me till death"

    But most of the time usually its the first option because no one wants to downgrade their ways of live when getting old.

    And the problem with the first one is that as more and more people want to do that, who is going to work for them? the opressed youth :)

    • hnfong 5 minutes ago
      > And the problem with the first one is that as more and more people want to do that, who is going to work for them? the opressed youth :)

      If only youth unemployment isn't a serious issue in modern societies.

      In reality, maybe AI robots.

  • snemvalts 50 minutes ago
    For those who don't want to run random python scripts locally https://engaging-data.com/fire-calculator/
    • krupan 22 minutes ago
      Is this the same project, or a different project that does the same thing. I took a quick glance at both and the descriptions are very similar
  • walrus01 23 minutes ago
    I think this would highly depend on figures for real estate and overall COL in the specific location where you intend to retire? And also major life choice possibilities like maybe selling your house and moving or choosing something smaller when theoretical children are fully grown and have moved out.
  • bariumbitmap 1 hour ago
    I swear I saw a version of this years ago on one of the popular tech blags like Coding Horror or Joel On Software. I briefly looked for it the other day and couldn't find it. Anyone happen to remember it? I think it was mainly about salaries and when stock options would vest.
    • Joel_Mckay 29 minutes ago
      If you live in New York, life will get complex without building supplementary passive income from a young age.

      If people live a slow-burn lifestyle, buy revenue property one can later demolish as needed, park unused cash in index funds, and split 7% between bullion & high-risk. Most folks will be fine when things eventually go sideways.

      Some people like to gamble, but they usually don't talk about their mistakes. =3

      • hdgvhicv 20 minutes ago
        > Some people like to gamble, but they usually don't talk about their mistakes

        I just saw a cnn headline in the lobby about people who are looking to sell their family home to buy ai stock

        They sure talk about mistakes before they happen

        • Joel_Mckay 9 minutes ago
          I am not Bullish on LLM firms given the -$2.50 profit per $1 revenue, or several trillion USD debt buried on page 60 of their reports. They can go be awesome without my cash, and I will cheer them on.

          Note, whomever floated that home-equity loan will be happy with their won profits. They win-win even if the loan defaults. Not everyone is so lucky... =3

          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rE75WvOtcu8

  • apparent 31 minutes ago
    Given the national debt (and the state debts in many cases), I do not feel comfortable assuming that tax rates will not change drastically. I wouldn't be surprised if Roth IRAs became taxable, at least for certain people. And there could be straight-up wealth taxes on "the millionaires" (which you pretty much have to be in order to FIRE.
    • gedy 15 minutes ago
      You mean retire at all. I think this would cause a civil war if govt pulled this.
  • estetlinus 4 minutes ago
    Retiring early sounds utterly boring.
  • vasco 16 minutes ago
    How much money do you need to allow yourself to be happy and start experiencing life?

    How can people not see FIRE is just a way to make you postpone what you want to do? Who cares what you can do when you're old and full of pains?

    • skybrian 6 minutes ago
      Why not both? Depending on what you make, it’s often possible to enjoy life and also spend less than you earn. You are enjoying life like someone with a lower salary would.
  • esafak 37 minutes ago
    If you'd written it in Javascript you could have hosted it on Github Pages.
    • fulafel 33 minutes ago
      You can use Pyodide for that, no need to stoop to JS.
  • tigerlily 56 minutes ago
    This is cool, but I for one hope to be able to continue to work until my last dying day.
    • krupan 24 minutes ago
      The idea here is you get to work, but you don't have to work.
    • Chinjut 22 minutes ago
      Retirement doesn't mean you can't work. It means you don't have to. It means you can work for yourself on your own interests instead of for some other boss who tells you what to do.
      • 0web 12 minutes ago
        Why not find a career and job that's enjoyable now without even having to defer all of this for later? Not just in software, but you could be flying planes, be in a travelling circus, learn to be a chef, etc. If the answer is you have too many commitments keeping you tied to your current job, then I'd argue that we should be optimising for that optionality rather than some arbitrary day to end the nightmare 40 years from now
        • Chinjut 3 minutes ago
          I don't want to fly a plane, be in a traveling circus, or be a chef. There are things I want to do, but the money spigots of our society aren't lining up to pay me to do them. I'm all for obtaining optionality through universal income. But optionality means also the optionality to retire.
        • globular-toast 6 minutes ago
          That worked out great for those of us who found software enjoyable...
    • sevenzero 52 minutes ago
      Used to think the same when joining the field and now I despise every minute I have to work on software I don't care about. AI even made it worse as I joined the field due to liking the coding part, not the results. Well, there isn't really an alternative for me either as there are basically no jobs I could learn that pay equally well...
      • __MatrixMan__ 3 minutes ago
        Then get a job that doesn't pay equally well. It'll probably be an upgrade.
      • SA9G 46 minutes ago
        Hopefully you can retire early and then work on software you do like!! All those glorious ideas you had... but didn't have the time for. But be careful on the retirement part, the numbers go out the window (Andersen not Microsoft) when inflation bites :-(
        • techcode 26 minutes ago
          Do numbers go completely out the window due to inflation?

          While the price of gas, real-estate, groceries doubled or tripled over the last 10-15 years (here in NL).

          It also seems that Stocks/ETFs also did the same, right?

          Some of the Tech/IT/AI (and hence to some extent also S&P500 that's heavy on those) increased even more. But even if we consider it an artificial bubble - loads of other more traditional industries/ETFs also grew similarly to inflation, didn't they?

          • SA9G 14 minutes ago
            You are right of course.... but one's risk tolerance diminishes with waning work income. So retired folks have less of their money in stocks/ETFs and are more exposed to the ravages of inflation.

            So with hindsight, one can easily weather inflation... only hindsight is hard to come by (says the guy who cancelled his NVIDIA buy order a few years back)!

          • hdgvhicv 16 minutes ago
            Gas as in petrol?

            It’s up 48% in 15 years, and until the Us-Iran war it was only up 14%

            https://fuelwide.com/fuel-prices/netherlands/history

            Grocery inflation is 45% over the same period but I suspect you’ll claim CPI figures are nonsense.

            Gas for heating has indeed about doubled, unsurprising with both Ukraine and Iran.

        • sevenzero 20 minutes ago
          I wont be able to retire early with a measly 2.5k net wage in Germany. Still, job market is dead here. Its all Java and basically zero interesting projects. I appreciate the kind words though!
      • carlosjobim 18 minutes ago
        Then your life is completely meaningless. You've rationalized yourself into wasting the one and only life you have.
      • paul7986 51 minutes ago
        How much coding are you doing nowadays vs. AI doing it for you and you reviewing/pushing it into the repo?
    • kipper8 44 minutes ago
      [flagged]