Why 'The Global Market' Is an Irresponsible Phrase

(oswarld.com)

14 points | by haebom 2 hours ago

8 comments

  • danielscrubs 29 minutes ago
    Kind of resonate with my experience, I built an app that only seemed to sell in San Francisco and some European capitals.

    Before release, I thought it would simply be correlated with population density, but I was very very wrong.

    It was an educational app, not related to IT…

  • cthalupa 1 hour ago
    This article could be summed up in one sentence as "Markets are more complicated than a country so saying you are targeting a country or continent as a market is too high level to convey an actionable plan."

    Which, yeah, sure, but did anyone ever think there was such thing as a "every person in America" or "every person in Korea" market for anything but the most universal of basic necessities?

    I'm not sure what I was expecting when I clicked this link, but what I ended up reading appears to just be AI blogspam.

  • groundzeros2015 1 hour ago
    Markets are largely defined by legal system, not that the culture of individuals within the jurisdiction are homogenous, but the way business is done.
    • mohsen1 1 hour ago
      It’s strange that the article says the white collar worker in nyc and small business owner in suburban Texas are not the same market. To many businesses they are in the same market. McDonald’s Home Depot etc they don’t make different products for those two individuals
      • bluGill 1 hour ago
        home depot doesn't have lucatations in Mahattan - I don't even need to check that made up fact to believe it. The market in manhattan cannot support home depot as it opperates in the Texas suburb. Even if they do happen to have a store there it would have to be different.
  • blitzar 1 hour ago
    I wrote something then realised I was writing a critique on SEO blogpost slop from a consultant for a consultancy. 3/10 - would not do again.
  • gostsamo 1 hour ago
    Some case studies would've been interesting. The rest is marketing copy to justify why they should be hired.
  • mschuster91 1 hour ago
    > Teams that start with translation almost always share the same failure pattern: They change the language, without changing the choice.

    Obligatory reminder to the utter failure of Walmart to enter the German market a few decades ago [1]: no respect for local labor laws was one thing (most of the competition openly sharted on it just as well), but what really did them in was the greeters, the forced smiles and the chants. Germans don't want to be coddled like Americans, Germans don't want to be treated like a religious cult at work, and the failure of Walmart to see this lost them over a billion dollars.

    [1] https://medium.com/the-global-millennial/why-walmart-failed-...

    • magicalhippo 1 hour ago
      I really don't get why large corporations seemingly don't do more homework when trying to get into a new market. Especially if they buy a successful company to do so, without doing any work figuring out why they're successful, nor rocking the boat.

      I worked at one of the largest IT companies here in Norway when it got sold to some international corporation. They drove it into the ground in less than 6 months, selling the tattered remains for scraps to our largest competitor.

      In my current job I've seen it multiple times with our competitors, where they're just a shadow of themselves after getting acquired by a large multinational.

      Good for us of course, we're now dominating our niche.

    • port3000 1 hour ago
      True. Interesting as well that Aldi Sud did the complete opposite when they entered the US with Trader Joe's - completely adapting the brand to the local market.
      • KellyCriterion 1 hour ago
        ...Id say that Aldi watched the market failure of Walmart in Gemany very closely and learnt massivly from that? :-)
  • yunohn 1 hour ago
    This article is so heavily edited by ChatGPT that every single sentence exhibits AI slop smells. It’s so hard to read anything these days without being put off by the repetitive robotic style of AI.