Show HN: We made a Meta Quest3 see through walls

(0xredj.medium.com)

50 points | by sleepingreset 131 days ago

4 comments

  • latexr 130 days ago
    > Show HN is for something you've made that other people can play with. HN users can try it out, give you feedback, and ask questions in the thread.

    That’s the first line of the Show HN rules.

    https://news.ycombinator.com/showhn.html

    This is just a blog post, and thus a regular submission and explicitly off-topic for Show HN. Everyone clicking on this will be disappointed, as demonstrated by the comments so far. There isn’t even a video for us to see the effect.

  • Philpax 130 days ago
    I understand that this was meant to be a retelling of how the build process went and what happened afterwards, but it seems quite light on the actual results? I would have liked to see a video demonstrating how well it lets the user see through walls!
    • moritonal 130 days ago
      "We didn’t qualify for the standard prizes — perhaps spending only 30 seconds on our presentation and lacking a live-demo setup had killed our chances."
      • Philpax 130 days ago
        That's the result of the competition, but what I want is a demonstration of the actual project: in an uncongested area, take a video of someone walking behind a wall and demonstrate that you can still locate them.
        • sleepingreset 130 days ago
          working on v2.0!! realizing how it comes across now. Oculus link does not allow for recording & we have a shitty mp4 in a google drive of it working thru a phone camera. Left this out because there wasn't time to compile. Just pasted everything into the medium blog. Rather than re-write, since we all flew home & separated the parts, I'm working on a souped up version w/ friends. We're designing a new pcb in kicad & just want to get something cleaner out. Happy to email an actual video though if you care to see the blurry pov
          • moritonal 123 days ago
            There's a brutal difference between a few nerds saying they have the coolest demo, and actually shipping it as something. It's a lesson we all go through, but the marketing and "release" of an idea is an important skill to perfect.
  • realty_geek 130 days ago
    Such a great project!! I suppose it is not getting many comments because it is such a niche concept.

    I think the HN algo rewards posts with a high points to comments ratio anyway which is a good thing in this case.

    • forrestthewoods 130 days ago
      It would get more comments if there was a video or screenshot or literally anything that shows the output of their project…
    • meindnoch 130 days ago
      There's no proof that it actually works.
      • sleepingreset 130 days ago
        see other comment on this thread. v2 soon :) will also repost with FOSS tutorial since i didn't realize rules of show hn. my apologies /gen
    • Dlooooloo 130 days ago
      I didn't comment or read it yesterday because it sounds click baity.

      Now I read it and find it weird. The core detail how 2 small noisy wifi chips would achieve a 90% detection rate is completely unexplained.

      The amount of data they get is minimal too, sounds more like voodoo than real

    • ekianjo 130 days ago
      This post is very light on actual demonstation of results.
  • EDEdDNEdDYFaN 130 days ago
    cool shit